Skip to content

Head to head

Amazon Kindle (first generation) vs Amazon Kindle Scribe

Dead level: both score 7.2. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Amazon Kindle (first generation)
  • E Ink that still reads like paper in daylight, with no light of its own
  • Whispernet delivers a book over cellular in a minute, with no computer and no bill
  • Page bars run the full height of both edges, so pages turn by accident
Cover of Amazon Kindle Scribe
  • Large, sharp screen is excellent for books, PDFs and comics
  • Pen writes smoothly and never needs charging
  • Handwriting in Kindle books was limited to sticky notes at launch

Where the gap is

Value
6.27.2
Design
5.58.4
Features
8.26.5
Performance
6.86.9

At a glance

FactAmazon Kindle (first generation)Amazon Kindle Scribe
Released19 November 200730 November 2022
MakerAmazonAmazon
TypeE-reader—
OsLinux-based Kindle firmware—
ChipMarvell XScale PXA255 at 400 MHz—
PortsUSB 2.0 mini-B, SD card slot, 3.5 mm stereo headphone jack, charging port—
GenreE reader · E inkTablet
Battery—12 weeks
Display—10.2" E-Ink 300ppi
Features—Pen support, 16-64GB

The two verdicts

Amazon Kindle (first generation)

Amazon Kindle (first generation): the awkward machine that started a category

The first Kindle is a poor piece of industrial design wrapped around an excellent idea. The screen is still good, the free cellular delivery was genuinely new, and the removable battery and SD slot are small acts of generosity that no later Kindle repeated. Against that: a body that turns pages by itself, a keyboard that earns no space, a scroll wheel that was obsolete on the day, a price of $399 that bought a device only Americans could use, and a catalogue locked to one shop. Scored as a device rather than as a turning point, it lands at good rather than great. The turning point it certainly was, and the two judgements do not have to agree.

Read the full review →

Amazon Kindle Scribe

Kindle Scribe: a lovely reading slate with note-taking that arrived half-built

The Kindle Scribe earns 7.2. The display, pen feel and battery life are excellent, and it stands as Amazon's best large-screen reader. The score is held back by writing features that launched incomplete, sluggish menus and a price that invites comparison with more capable note-taking devices. It improved after launch, but its identity as a reader first remained clear.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.