La La Land · 2016
La La Land: a bittersweet valentine to dreamers and old Hollywood musicals
La La Land review: Damien Chazelle's romantic musical is dazzling and wistful, with Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling at their most charming, if vocally modest.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
La La Land is a love letter to Los Angeles, to jazz and to the classic Hollywood musical, but it is also a melancholy film about the costs of ambition. Damien Chazelle, following his intense drumming drama Whiplash, uses the colourful, joyous language of old studio musicals and French films such as The Umbrellas of Cherbourg to tell a modern story of two artists trying to make it. It was an enormous critical and awards success, winning Academy Awards including Best Director for Chazelle and Best Actress for Stone.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #66
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2016
- Released
- 9.1
- Best at: Craft
It also inspired a strong backlash, with some viewers finding it nostalgic to a fault. Both reactions have some basis.
Justin Hurwitz's score, including the Oscar-winning City of Stars and a haunting recurring theme, is lush and memorable.
Seasons of love
The film is structured by seasons, beginning in winter with a showstopping number on a gridlocked freeway interchange, where drivers leap from their cars to sing and dance. The sequence, staged to appear as a continuous shot, announces the film's ambition. Mia and Sebastian's first meetings are prickly, and their romance develops through a series of musical encounters, including a tap dance above the city at twilight and a trip to the Griffith Observatory where they float among the stars.
These scenes are enchanting. As the relationship deepens and their careers take hold, however, the musical numbers become fewer, and the middle section, involving Sebastian joining a commercially successful band, loses some of the film's early momentum.

Stone and Gosling
Emma Stone is terrific as Mia, conveying the humiliation of auditions and the resilience required to keep trying. Her solo number late in the film, an audition song about her aunt who inspired her to perform, is a moving centrepiece. Ryan Gosling brings wit and romantic intensity to Sebastian, and he learned to play the piano pieces himself.
Their chemistry, established in earlier films together, is effortless. But neither is a trained singer or dancer, and the musical numbers are pleasant rather than dazzling in their execution, which some viewers found a disappointment compared with the classics the film evokes.
Jazz and nostalgia
Sebastian's passion for traditional jazz and his contempt for modern, commercial music drive much of the conflict. His relationship with John Legend's Keith, a successful musician who embraces newer sounds, is intriguing, but the film's framing, in which a white musician is positioned as jazz's defender, was criticised by several commentators. The film's nostalgia for past forms can also feel more reverent than questioning.
Craft
Linus Sandgren's cinematography uses vivid primary colours and swooping camera moves, while David Wasco's production design and Mary Zophres' costumes evoke classic Hollywood. Justin Hurwitz's score, including the Oscar-winning City of Stars and a haunting recurring theme, is lush and memorable.
The film's final sequence, an imaginative epilogue best left unspoiled, is widely regarded as its emotional high point, reframing the love story with bittersweet power.
What works
- The freeway opening number is exhilarating and technically bold
- Emma Stone's audition song is a moving showcase
- Justin Hurwitz's score is lush, melodic and memorable
- A wistful epilogue that gives the romance lasting resonance
What doesn’t
- Stone and Gosling's singing and dancing are charming but modest
- Sebastian's role as jazz's saviour has drawn fair criticism
- The middle stretch loses momentum as musical numbers thin out
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.19.4
- Story
- 8.08.5
- Direction
- 9.09.2
- Performances
- 8.59.4
Phantom Thread edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
La La Land is a beautifully crafted, emotionally resonant musical with charming performances and a remarkable final act. Its modest vocals, slower middle section and nostalgic blind spots prevent it from being a genuine classic of the form, but its romance and ambition are hard to resist. It earns an 8.4.





