Phantom Thread · 2017
Phantom Thread: an exquisitely tailored romance with a wicked sense of humour
Phantom Thread review: Paul Thomas Anderson's 1950s London couture drama is a sumptuous, strange and darkly funny study of love, control and devotion.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Phantom Thread looks, at first glance, like a handsome period drama about a fashion designer and his muse. It is something considerably stranger and more interesting: a sly, perverse and often very funny love story about two people fighting for control, and about the unexpected forms that intimacy can take. Paul Thomas Anderson treats this material with the same meticulous care his protagonist lavishes on silk and lace.
- 8.8
- Editorial score
- #41
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2017
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Craft
It is a film of precise gestures and small, sharp shocks, and its pleasures deepen on revisiting as the audience notices how carefully every stitch has been placed.
Lesley Manville is superb as Cyril, whose few words carry the authority of someone who has managed her brother's temperament for decades.
Story
Reynolds Woodcock is a man of ruinous exactitude. Breakfast must be silent, disruptions intolerable, and women in his life are welcome only until they begin to require anything of him. His sister Cyril manages the business and, in effect, him. When he meets Alma at a hotel in the countryside, their courtship begins with an extravagant breakfast order and a fitting that is both flattering and faintly clinical.
What follows is a battle of wills conducted through meals, dresses and illnesses. Alma is not the passive muse Reynolds expects. Anderson's screenplay lets the dynamic develop in surprising directions, and the film's later passages take a dark, almost fairy-tale turn that some viewers find delicious and others find disturbing. It should be discovered rather than described.
Direction and craft
Anderson served as his own cinematographer, uncredited, and the images have a soft, grainy warmth that evokes the era without looking like a museum piece. The camera lingers on fabric, hands and faces, and the House of Woodcock, a tall Georgian townhouse full of seamstresses and staircases, becomes a character in its own right.
Mark Bridges' costume design, which won an Academy Award, is integral to the storytelling rather than decorative; Reynolds' dresses express his moods and his power. Jonny Greenwood's score, sweeping and romantic with echoes of mid-century film music and piano works, gives the film a swooning quality that plays beautifully against its prickly characters. The sound design is equally clever, turning the scrape of butter on toast into an act of aggression.
Performances
Daniel Day-Lewis gives Reynolds an elegance that barely conceals a spoilt, needy child. His performance is funnier than expected, especially in moments of wounded fury over tea, and it is shot through with a vulnerability that emerges slowly. Vicky Krieps, then relatively little known to international audiences, is his match in every sense. Her Alma appears gentle, but Krieps lets the audience see the calculation and the fierce devotion beneath her calm.
Lesley Manville is superb as Cyril, whose few words carry the authority of someone who has managed her brother's temperament for decades. The three form a triangle of shifting loyalties that is endlessly watchable.
Who it is for
Phantom Thread will delight viewers who appreciate slow-burning character studies, gothic romances and films in which small gestures carry huge weight. Those who prefer brisk plotting, or who find emotionally chilly characters off-putting, may find its world airless. It is best approached as a dark comedy of manners as much as a romance.
What works
- Daniel Day-Lewis makes a fastidious, petulant genius oddly magnetic
- Vicky Krieps holds her own as Alma, steadily shifting the balance of power
- Jonny Greenwood's lush, romantic score is among his very best work
- Costumes and interiors create a world of hushed, suffocating elegance
What doesn’t
- Its languid pace and chilly surface can feel airless to some viewers
- The relationship's twisted logic may repel rather than intrigue
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.49.1
- Story
- 8.58.0
- Direction
- 9.29.0
- Performances
- 9.48.5
Phantom Thread edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Phantom Thread is a gorgeously made, superbly acted film that grows richer with each viewing, and it was widely admired as one of Anderson's most refined works. Its deliberately limited scope and unsettling central relationship will not suit every taste, and its tempo can feel stately to a fault. Still, it is a near-flawless piece of craftsmanship and an unforgettable portrait of an unconventional love.




