Mare of Easttown · 2021
Mare of Easttown: a small-town murder mystery with a big, bruised heart
Our review of Mare of Easttown, HBO's limited crime drama: Kate Winslet leads a gripping, grief-soaked mystery rooted in a vividly drawn community.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Mare of Easttown takes a familiar format, the small-town murder investigation, and grounds it in something more specific: the textures of a close-knit, struggling community where everyone knows everyone and grief touches almost every household. It became one of HBO's most talked-about series of its year, and a large part of that success rests on Kate Winslet's commanding, understated lead performance.
- 8.4
- Editorial score
- #46
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 1
- Seasons
It is a very good crime drama rather than a revolutionary one. Its puzzle is well made and its characters are rich, but its devices, from red herrings to cliffhangers, are the traditional tools of the genre.
Fans of character-driven crime dramas, such as British detective series or earlier HBO mysteries, will find it immensely satisfying.
Story
The series opens with Mare already under strain. A girl has been missing for a year, her mother is publicly angry about the lack of progress and Mare is exhausted, drinking too much and struggling to connect with her family. When a teenage mother is found dead in a creek, the investigation reveals a web of relationships, secrets and resentments across the town.
Brad Ingelsby's script is skilful at building suspicion. Across seven episodes, suspicion moves between family members, boyfriends, neighbours and even members of the local church, and the reveals are timed to maintain tension without cheating. The show is equally interested in Mare's personal life: her fraught relationships with her mother, daughter and ex-husband, a custody struggle over her grandson and a loss she refuses to confront. The final episode's resolution is widely regarded as well earned and emotionally powerful. The large suspect pool, though, occasionally means that characters are introduced primarily to be suspected, and a romance with Guy Pearce's writer is pleasant but slight.

Characters and performances
Kate Winslet disappears into Mare. With a convincing regional accent, a vape pen and a weary sarcasm, she creates a character whose toughness is plainly a defence against pain. It is a performance of great detail and no vanity. Jean Smart provides wonderful comic relief as Mare's blunt mother, and their bickering is often very funny. Julianne Nicholson gives Lori a quiet, devastating strength. Evan Peters, as a young detective eager to impress Mare, brings unexpected warmth, and Angourie Rice and Cailee Spaeny are excellent in smaller roles.
Craft
Craig Zobel, who directed every episode, gives the series a consistent, unshowy style. The town's clapboard houses, bars, diners and parish halls are captured with authentic detail, and the muted palette suits the grey Pennsylvania setting. The approach prioritises performance and place over visual invention, which serves the story but makes the show look more conventional than some peers. The pacing is disciplined, with each episode ending on a strong hook.
Who it is for
Fans of character-driven crime dramas, such as British detective series or earlier HBO mysteries, will find it immensely satisfying. It deals with drug addiction, child endangerment and suicide, and some scenes are harrowing. Its limited length makes it an easy commitment.
What works
- Kate Winslet gives a lived-in, unglamorous and completely convincing lead
- Easttown feels like a real, tightly knit community
- The whodunit is well plotted with a satisfying resolution
- Jean Smart and Julianne Nicholson excel in key supporting roles
What doesn’t
- A crowded field of suspects leans on red herrings
- Some subplots, including Mare's romance, feel underdeveloped
- Visually functional rather than distinctive
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.27.8
- Story
- 8.26.9
- Characters
- 8.87.3
- Performances
- 9.38.5
Mare of Easttown edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
Mare of Easttown earns an 8.4 for Kate Winslet's superb central performance, a strong supporting cast and a mystery that is both cleverly built and emotionally resonant. Its reliance on red herrings, thinly drawn subplots and conventional visual style prevent it from reaching the very top tier, but it is an exemplary limited series.





