Mass Effect 2 · 2010
Mass Effect 2: BioWare's character-driven heist in space still sets the bar
Mass Effect 2 has Commander Shepard recruit a crew for a suicide mission against the Collectors, and remains one of the finest sci-fi RPGs ever made.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Mass Effect 2 is essentially a recruitment drama wearing the clothes of a space opera. The threat is galactic, but the game's real subject is the people Shepard gathers aboard the Normandy, and it is in that shift of focus that BioWare found the series' best form. More than a decade on, few RPGs have matched how much its cast feels like the point of the whole enterprise.
- 9.2
- Editorial score
- #24
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2010
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Story
It is not flawless. Some systems were simplified too aggressively, and resource gathering is a slog. But the structure is so well judged that those irritations fade quickly.
More than a decade on, few RPGs have matched how much its cast feels like the point of the whole enterprise.
How it plays
Combat is a marked improvement on the first game. Cover is responsive, weapons feel distinct, and the power wheel lets players pause and direct squad abilities, combining biotic, tech and combat skills against shields, armour and barriers. It is not the most sophisticated shooter of its era, but it is consistently satisfying.
The RPG side is leaner. The sprawling inventory of the original has gone, replaced by a handful of weapon choices and research upgrades. That keeps momentum up, at the cost of some tinkering depth that role-playing purists missed. Exploration of uncharted worlds was also pared back, and the planet scanning mini-game that feeds upgrades quickly becomes tedious.

World and characters
The structure is where the game shines. Shepard reviews dossiers, recruits specialists across the galaxy and then earns their loyalty through personal missions: settling a family feud, confronting a past crime, dealing with the ethics of a biological weapon. Each mission reveals new corners of the setting, from criminal havens to alien homeworlds, while making the character at its centre more complicated.
Conversations aboard the ship do the rest. Mordin, Garrus, Tali, Thane, Jack and the others are sharply written and memorably performed, and the dynamic of working for Cerberus, an organisation Shepard has every reason to distrust, adds a welcome undercurrent of tension.
The overarching Collector storyline is comparatively slight, largely a framework to justify the recruitment arc. What rescues it is the finale: the success of the last mission depends heavily on how thoroughly players prepared their crew and ship, and it converts dozens of hours of choices into stakes that feel personal.
Presentation
The darker, grittier art direction suits the story's more morally grey tone, and cutscenes and facial animation were strong for the time. The score blends synthesiser moods with more urgent orchestral cues. Some environments, particularly corridors between combat arenas, are functional rather than inspiring, and the original release shows its age next to the later remastered collection.
Who it is for
Anyone interested in story-led RPGs should play it, ideally after the first game so imported choices carry weight. Players looking for open exploration or deep loot systems will find it more focused than they might expect.
What works
- A superb ensemble cast, each with a loyalty mission that deepens them
- The final mission turns earlier preparation into real, felt consequences
- Tighter cover shooting and powers fix the first game's clumsy combat
- Choices imported from the first game give the universe a lived-in continuity
What doesn’t
- Planet scanning for resources is slow, repetitive busywork
- Streamlined inventory and levelling strip out some RPG depth
- The central Collector plot is thinner than the character stories around it
Head to head
- Story
- 9.59.0
- Gameplay
- 8.68.0
- Longevity
- 8.98.2
- Presentation
- 8.89.0
Mass Effect 2 edges it by 1.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Mass Effect 2 builds an entire game around the idea that companions matter, then proves it with loyalty missions and a finale shaped by preparation. Streamlined systems and tedious scanning are genuine faults, and the main plot is thin, yet the writing, structure and cast make it one of the defining RPGs of its generation and worthy of an exceptional score.





