Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain · 2015
Metal Gear Solid V: a stealth sandbox of genius around an unfinished story
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain offers the most flexible stealth play in the genre, but its fractured, incomplete story leaves a lingering ache.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
The Phantom Pain may contain the finest stealth mechanics ever put into a game. Every system, from the way Snake slides into cover to how guards react to a missing patrol member, is built to support improvisation, and the open maps turn each mission into a puzzle with dozens of valid solutions. It is also a game that feels unmistakably incomplete, and that tension defines it.
- 9.0
- Editorial score
- #44
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Gameplay
What remains is an astonishing toy box attached to a story that never quite assembles itself.
The Fox Engine was a technical triumph on release, delivering smooth performance, realistic lighting and dynamic weather.
How it plays
Missions drop Snake into open regions with a goal and very little instruction. Players can scout outposts with binoculars, tag guards, time an approach to a sandstorm or nightfall, and choose between silent infiltration, tranquillising everyone or a loud, vehicle-led assault. Buddies expand the options further: a horse for quick escapes, a dog that spots enemies, a sniper who provides cover, or a walker for heavier firepower.
The Fulton recovery system, which lifts unconscious soldiers, animals and even vehicles off to Mother Base, is both comic and strategically central. Recruited staff improve research and development, unlocking new gadgets that open fresh approaches. The enemy also adapts: rely on headshots and guards start wearing helmets; favour night raids and they bring floodlights. It is a clever way of discouraging a single dominant strategy.
The structure is less elegant. After the first chapter, a significant portion of the mission list consists of earlier operations replayed with tougher conditions, and the open world itself is largely empty between outposts.

World and story
Kojima's storytelling here is more restrained than in previous entries, with far fewer lengthy cutscenes. The opening hours are strikingly directed and unsettling, and there are memorable sequences throughout. Yet a large share of the plot is delivered through optional cassette tapes, and the pacing becomes uneven after the first chapter, with key characters fading into the background.
The publicised split between Kojima and Konami during development has become part of how the game is read, and its unresolved threads support the widely held view that parts of the planned story were never finished. For series devotees, its themes of revenge, identity and loss still land, but the narrative lacks the cohesion of the best Metal Gear entries.
Presentation
The Fox Engine was a technical triumph on release, delivering smooth performance, realistic lighting and dynamic weather. Animation is exceptional and gives movement a tactile weight. The licensed 1980s soundtrack, available on cassettes found in the field, gives the game a distinctive mood, and Kiefer Sutherland's quieter take on Snake fits the more reticent script.
Who it is for
Anyone who enjoys systemic stealth or player-driven problem solving should play it. Fans seeking a conclusive, cinematic Metal Gear story may find it frustrating, even as they admire the mechanics.
What works
- Missions can be tackled in countless improvised ways with tools and buddies
- Enemy adaptation forces players to vary tactics rather than repeat one trick
- Fox Engine controls feel precise, responsive and physically convincing
- Mother Base management ties every extraction back to a larger loop
What doesn’t
- The second chapter leans heavily on harder replays of earlier missions
- Much of the story is delivered through cassette tapes rather than scenes
- Narrative threads are left conspicuously unresolved
Head to head
- Story
- 6.87.8
- Gameplay
- 9.89.8
- Longevity
- 9.19.6
- Presentation
- 9.09.4
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
As a stealth sandbox, The Phantom Pain is close to peerless, with a depth of systems and freedom that few games have approached. Its repetitive second half, sparse world and fragmented, unfinished story are real faults, but the brilliance of its moment-to-moment play still earns it a score of nine.





