Middlemarch · 1871
Middlemarch: a whole town held in one patient, forgiving gaze
Middlemarch review. George Eliot's 1871–72 novel of a Midlands town before the Reform Act is long, slow to start and the most humane English novel of its century.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
Middlemarch is a long novel about people who do not get what they want, and it is one of the least depressing books in English. George Eliot follows a provincial town through three years of small ambitions, bad marriages, debts, gossip and the occasional act of plain decency, and she treats every person in it as though their inner life were as large as her own. Nobody in Middlemarch is a villain for long. Everyone is a reason.
- 9.5
- Editorial score
- #2
- Of 61 books reviewed
- 1871
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Characters
That generosity is the point, and also the price. The book is close to nine hundred pages in a modern paperback, it takes its time introducing a cast that keeps growing for several hundred of them, and its first readers took a year to get through it in eight instalments. Readers who arrive expecting a period romance will find something slower and stranger: a novel that keeps stopping to ask why people choose what they choose, and answers more honestly than most of its successors have managed.
The premise
The novel opens on Dorothea Brooke, not yet twenty, orphaned, comfortably off and impatient with the small pleasures her class offers young women. She wants to do something that matters, and she mistakes Edward Casaubon, a dry clergyman decades older who is writing a vast work of mythological scholarship, for a mind she can serve. Her sister Celia sees straight through him. Dorothea does not, and within a few chapters she has accepted him.
Alongside her runs a second story that Eliot had begun separately and later merged into this one. Tertius Lydgate is a young doctor, trained in Edinburgh and Paris, who comes to Middlemarch meaning to practise modern medicine and do serious research on the side. He is clever, principled about his work and careless about money, and he notices Rosamond Vincy, the mayor's daughter, in the way a man notices someone he has decided is not a serious prospect. Rosamond's brother Fred, meanwhile, is running up debts against an inheritance he expects from a rich old uncle.
1869
Eliot begins a novel about a provincial doctor, provisionally titled Middlemarch
1870
She starts a separate long story, Miss Brooke, about a young woman of ardent temperament
1871
The two are joined; the first part, Miss Brooke, appears from Blackwood in December
1872
The eighth part completes the serial in December, alongside a four-volume edition
1994
The BBC adapts the novel for television, directed by Anthony Page from a screenplay by Andrew Davies
The merging of those two drafts is visible in the finished book, and it is a strength. Dorothea's story is about vocation and marriage; Lydgate's is about vocation and marriage too, approached from the other side. Eliot sets them running in parallel, lets the town's gossip carry news between them, and builds a novel out of rhymes rather than a single plot.

The writing
Eliot's narrator is the most distinctive thing in the book. She often speaks as "we", steps into the scene to generalise about human nature, and then returns to it with the general point turned into something particular. A paragraph about Dorothea's tears in Rome becomes, in the space of two sentences, an observation about how little anyone can bear to notice of other people's pain.
If we had a keen vision and feeling of all ordinary human life, it would be like hearing the grass grow and the squirrel's heart beat, and we should die of that roar which lies on the other side of silence.
The sentences are long, balanced and full of qualifications, and they reward reading slowly in a way that most Victorian prose does not. There is also much more comedy than the novel's reputation suggests. Mr Brooke, Dorothea's uncle, is a magistrate who collects opinions the way other men collect snuffboxes, and every one of his speeches wanders off before it reaches a point. The town's chorus of doctors, clergymen and auctioneers is written with a satirist's ear for self-interest dressed as principle.
Each chapter opens with an epigraph, some quoted from other writers and many composed by Eliot herself. They work as small tuning forks for what follows, and they are one of the reasons the book reads in sittings rather than as a single block.
Story and structure
Middlemarch has the machinery of a sensation novel buried inside it: inheritances, wills, debts and reputations that rest on less than their owners would like. Eliot handles all of it at walking pace and without cliffhangers, which can make the middle of the book seem eventless to anyone reading for plot. It is not eventless. The events are simply weighed by their consequences rather than staged for their surprise.
How it reads
- Pace
- 4/10
- Unhurried throughout; the first book is the slowest
- Density
- 9/10
- Every chapter carries several lives forward at once
- Humour
- 7/10
- Frequent, dry, and mostly at the expense of the self-important
- Period context
- 7/10
- Reform politics, medical reform and railways all assumed
- Re-reading value
- 10/10
- Details planted early pay out hundreds of pages later
The eight books each carry a title, and several of them say more about what is coming than this review will. The structure follows the town rather than any one person: when Dorothea's story pauses, Lydgate's advances, and when both rest, the Garths or the Vincys take over. The effect, over the length of the book, is of a community whose members are constantly affecting each other without knowing it, which is exactly what Eliot set out to describe.
Characters
Dorothea is the novel's heart, but Eliot refuses to let her be its heroine in the usual sense. Her idealism is admirable and also, at her age, a form of blindness, and the novel is merciless about the cost of that blindness without once mocking her for it. Lydgate is her counterpart: a man whose ambitions are entirely real and whose small flaws, a certain pride and a habit of not looking closely at domestic things, turn out to matter more than his large virtues.
The supporting cast would carry several lesser novels. Casaubon, who could have been a caricature of the pedant, becomes one of the saddest people in English fiction once Eliot shows him from the inside. Rosamond is a study of a mind that is entirely self-contained, written with a precision that is almost frightening. Mary Garth, plain, sharp and funny, and her father Caleb, a land agent who regards good work as a form of religion, supply the book's moral ballast without sermonising.
The ideas
The novel is set in the years just before the 1832 Reform Act, with the railway surveyors arriving and cholera on the horizon, and it was written forty years later by someone who knew how those changes turned out. That distance lets Eliot write about reform, scientific medicine and women's education with irony and sympathy at once. Her characters believe they are living through a turning point. They are, and they are also mostly occupied with rent, reputation and who will marry whom.
The central idea is about scale. Eliot is interested in what happens to large ambitions inside small lives, and in whether a life that leaves no public mark can still count for something. She does not answer the question with consolation. She answers it with attention, and that is why the book reads as a contemporary novel about anyone who has ever settled for less than they meant to do. Readers who came to The Remains of the Day for its picture of a life spent in the wrong service will find the same question here, asked across a whole town rather than a single house.
Head to head
- Ideas
- 9.69.1
- Story
- 9.08.1
- Writing
- 9.79.6
- Characters
- 9.89.4
Middlemarch edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
Editions and how to read it
The text is out of copyright and free to read online, but an annotated edition is worth having: the politics, the medicine and the many quotations in the epigraphs all benefit from notes. Any of the main paperback editions will serve; the Penguin Classics edition is the one we recommend for a first reading.
| Edition | Year | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|
| Blackwood, eight parts | 1871–72 | The original serial, issued in paper wrappers over thirteen months |
| Penguin Classics, ed. Rosemary Ashton | 2003 | 880 pages; the standard paperback in the UK, ISBN 978-0-14-143954-9 |
| Oxford University Press | 2019 | A scholarly paperback alternative to the Penguin |
| W. W. Norton | 2023 | A recent American paperback |
| Project Gutenberg | Free | The full public-domain text, without notes |
Reading it in eight sittings, one per book, recreates something of the first readers' experience and gives each book's events room to settle. Readers who find the opening chapters slow should push on to the arrival of Lydgate, where the second engine of the novel starts.
For you if
- Readers who like long novels that take their time with people
- Anyone interested in marriage, money and ambition as they actually work
- Readers who enjoy a narrator with opinions and the intelligence to justify them
Not for you if
- Anyone who wants a fast plot or a clear romantic arc
- Readers impatient with digressions on politics, medicine or human nature
- Anyone looking for a short introduction to Victorian fiction
For a first reading, the choice of edition matters more than it does for most classics, because the notes carry so much of the period detail.
What works
- A narrator who explains every character's motives, including the ones we dislike
- Four interlocking plots, each strong enough to carry a shorter novel alone
- Marriage treated as a working arrangement, with money and ambition priced in
- Short epigraphs and chapters make an 880-page book easy to read in sittings
What doesn’t
- The first hundred pages ask for patience before the town comes into focus
- Reform politics and medical debates assume context a modern reader lacks
- The narrator's essays on human nature sometimes stop the scene to deliver them
The verdict
Middlemarch earns its place near the top of the scale because it does something few novels attempt and almost none sustain: it gives an entire community the same depth of attention, and it makes that attention feel like a moral act rather than a technique. The writing is dense, funny and exact; the characters, from Dorothea to the least of the town's gossips, are understood rather than judged. What holds it a fraction below the very top is the cost of entry. The opening is slow, the period detail is heavy, and the narrator's habit of pausing to reflect will not suit every reader. For anyone willing to give it the first hundred pages, it repays the rest many times over, and it reads differently at every age.




