Skip to content
Series reviewExcellent

Mindhunter · 2017

Mindhunter: a chilling, cerebral crime drama that stopped far too soon

Our review of Mindhunter, David Fincher's Netflix crime drama: gripping killer interviews and precise craft in a story that was left unfinished.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Mindhunter is a crime drama without car chases, shootouts or tidy resolutions. Its drama lies in conversation: two FBI agents sitting across tables from some of the most notorious killers in American history, trying to understand what makes them tick. Guided by David Fincher, whose films have long explored obsession and violence, the series is methodical, atmospheric and deeply unsettling. It is also, frustratingly, incomplete, with Netflix placing it on indefinite hold after two seasons.

8.8
Editorial score
#22
Of 109 series reviewed
2017
Released
2
Seasons

That unfinished quality does not diminish what is here. Mindhunter remains one of the most intelligent and stylish crime dramas of its time.

Mindhunter remains one of the most intelligent and stylish crime dramas of its time.

Story

The first season follows Holden and Bill as they begin a project interviewing incarcerated murderers, initially dismissed by colleagues but increasingly influential. Each conversation reveals disturbing insights, and the agents apply what they learn to active cases in small towns across America. The show is also interested in the effect the work has on its investigators, particularly Holden, whose growing confidence tips into recklessness.

The second season expands its scope, centring on the investigation into the Atlanta child murders of the late 1970s and early 1980s. This storyline allows the show to examine race, politics and the limits of profiling, and it is gripping and morally complex. Brief cold opens across both seasons follow a man in Kansas whose identity real-life crime enthusiasts will recognise, building a sense of dread that the show never had the chance to pay off. Some subplots, including Bill's troubles at home, are slow, though they add emotional depth.

Mindhunter
MindhunterNetflix

Characters and performances

Jonathan Groff makes Holden awkward, driven and sometimes insufferable, a character whose intellectual arrogance is central to the drama, though his development can feel uneven. Holt McCallany is excellent as Bill, a gruff, principled agent whose weariness grows as the job takes its toll. Anna Torv brings precision and loneliness to Wendy, a psychologist working in a male-dominated field.

The killers are the show's most striking element. Cameron Britton's Ed Kemper, polite, articulate and terrifying, is unforgettable. Other portrayals, including Damon Herriman's Charles Manson, are equally compelling. The show avoids sensationalising these men, using their words to reveal the banal and horrifying logic of their crimes.

Watch
Mindhunter — trailer

Craft

Mindhunter looks immaculate. Fincher, who directed several episodes including the opening and closing chapters of the first season, gives the series a cold, precise style, with carefully composed shots, muted colours and deliberate pacing. The period detail is impeccable, from offices to cars, and the soundtrack uses 1970s rock and pop to strong effect. The interview scenes, built on patient editing and closely framed faces, generate more tension than most action sequences.

Gallery · 3 imagesNetflix

Who it is for

Mindhunter is ideal for viewers who enjoy slow-burn crime dramas, psychological studies and true crime. It is dialogue-heavy and occasionally deliberately paced. It contains disturbing descriptions of violence, although it rarely shows it graphically.

What works

  • Interrogation scenes are riveting, disturbing and superbly written
  • Cameron Britton's Ed Kemper is a mesmerising, unsettling portrayal
  • Fincher's precise, controlled direction creates constant tension
  • The Atlanta child murders arc is a powerful, complex investigation

What doesn’t

  • Holden's arc can feel abrupt and his arrogance difficult to engage with
  • The show was halted before resolving its long-running threads
  • Some domestic subplots move at a painfully slow pace

Head to head

Craft
9.47.8
Story
8.57.5
Characters
8.78.2
Performances
9.19.0

Mindhunter edges it by 0.9. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Mindhunter earns an 8.8 for its riveting interviews, outstanding performances and David Fincher's meticulous craft. Its slow domestic subplots, a lead character who can be hard to warm to and the unresolved threads left by its cancellation keep it from the highest tier, but what exists is an exceptional study of darkness and the people who try to understand it.

Quick answers

Is Mindhunter worth watching?

Voxizer scores Mindhunter (2017) 8.8 out of 10 — excellent. Mindhunter earns an 8. 8 for its riveting interviews, outstanding performances and David Fincher's meticulous craft.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Mindhunter yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for series: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.