Moonlight · 2016
Moonlight: Barry Jenkins' luminous, three-part portrait of a hidden life
Moonlight review: Barry Jenkins' Best Picture winner is a tender, beautifully crafted study of identity and masculinity, told in three unforgettable chapters.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Moonlight is a film of extraordinary delicacy. Barry Jenkins tells the story of a quiet, bullied boy who becomes a hardened man, exploring Black masculinity, sexuality, poverty and love with an intimacy rarely seen on screen. Its three-chapter structure, lyrical visual style and remarkable performances made it a landmark of American independent cinema. It won the Academy Award for Best Picture, as well as awards for Mahershala Ali and for its adapted screenplay.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #24
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2016
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Performances
Its victory is often remembered for the envelope mix-up at the ceremony, but the film itself deserves to be remembered on its own considerable merits.
He has built a muscular, armoured exterior, complete with gold grills and a car modelled on Juan's, but his eyes still hold the frightened boy.
Little
The first chapter follows Chiron as a small, withdrawn boy known as Little, played by Alex Hibbert. Chased by bullies, he hides in an abandoned apartment, where he is found by Juan, a Cuban-born drug dealer played by Mahershala Ali. Juan and his girlfriend Teresa, played by Janelle Monáe, offer Little food, shelter and kindness.
Ali's performance, though brief, is unforgettable. Juan is gentle and wise, and in a beautiful scene he teaches Little to swim in the ocean. Yet the film does not simplify him: Juan sells drugs to Little's mother, and the moment he is confronted with this contradiction is devastating. Naomie Harris, as Paula, gives a harrowing performance as a mother whose addiction consumes her love.

Chiron
In the second chapter, Chiron, played by Ashton Sanders, is a lanky, painfully shy teenager facing relentless bullying at school. His friendship with his classmate Kevin develops into a moment of tender intimacy on a moonlit beach, a scene of quiet beauty. Its aftermath leads to a devastating betrayal and a turning point in Chiron's life.
Sanders conveys Chiron's vulnerability with heartbreaking physicality, his body hunched as if trying to disappear.
Black
The final chapter introduces the adult Chiron, now known as Black and played by Trevante Rhodes. He has built a muscular, armoured exterior, complete with gold grills and a car modelled on Juan's, but his eyes still hold the frightened boy. An unexpected phone call from Kevin, now played by André Holland, leads to a reunion in a Miami diner.
This extended scene is the film's emotional peak, full of hesitation, longing and unspoken history. Rhodes and Holland play it with extraordinary restraint, and its quietness is overwhelming.
The film's ellipses between chapters mean that major events happen off screen, and some viewers may wish to know more about how Chiron changed. But this approach is essential to the film's poetry.
Craft
James Laxton's cinematography uses vivid colours, close-ups and a swirling, handheld camera to make Miami both vibrant and dreamlike. Nicholas Britell's score blends classical strings with hip-hop techniques, including a chopped-and-screwed approach that slows and deepens the music. Jenkins frequently has characters look directly into the camera, creating an intimate connection with the audience.
What works
- Three actors form a seamless, heartbreaking portrait of Chiron
- Mahershala Ali gives Juan warmth, dignity and contradiction
- Lush cinematography makes Miami vivid and dreamlike
- The diner reunion is one of the most tender scenes in modern film
What doesn’t
- Long ellipses between chapters leave some events unexplored
- The restrained, elliptical style may frustrate some viewers
- Juan's role is brief relative to his impact on the story
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.19.2
- Story
- 8.99.2
- Direction
- 9.49.3
- Performances
- 9.58.8
Moonlight edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Moonlight is a beautifully crafted and deeply moving film that tells a story of identity and love with rare grace. Its ellipses and restraint will not suit every viewer, but its performances, visual poetry and emotional honesty are exceptional. It earns a 9.1 as one of the defining films of its decade.





