Skip to content

Head to head

Arrival vs Moonlight

Moonlight takes it by 0.1, 9.1 against 9.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Arrival
Arrival

2016 · Essential

  • Makes the process of learning a language thrilling on screen
  • Amy Adams gives a restrained, deeply felt central performance
  • Jeremy Renner's physicist is sketchy beside Adams' Louise
Cover of Moonlight
Moonlight

2016 · Essential

  • Three actors form a seamless, heartbreaking portrait of Chiron
  • Mahershala Ali gives Juan warmth, dignity and contradiction
  • Long ellipses between chapters leave some events unexplored

Where the gap is

Craft
9.29.1
Story
9.28.9
Direction
9.39.4
Performances
8.89.5

At a glance

FactArrivalMoonlight
Released11 November 201621 October 2016
DirectorDenis VilleneuveBarry Jenkins
StarringAmy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Forest WhitakerNaomie Harris, Trevante Rhodes, André Holland
Runtime116 minutes111 minutes
StudioParamount PicturesA24, Plan B Entertainment
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · MysteryDrama

The two verdicts

Arrival

Arrival: a first-contact story where the real spectacle is language itself

Arrival is intelligent, moving and beautifully crafted, treating its audience as capable of following complex ideas without sacrificing emotional impact. Its supporting characters and global politics are thinner than its central thread, but those limitations barely dent a film of such clarity and feeling. It earns a 9.0 as one of the finest science-fiction films of the 2010s.

Read the full review →

Moonlight

Moonlight: Barry Jenkins' luminous, three-part portrait of a hidden life

Moonlight is a beautifully crafted and deeply moving film that tells a story of identity and love with rare grace. Its ellipses and restraint will not suit every viewer, but its performances, visual poetry and emotional honesty are exceptional. It earns a 9.1 as one of the defining films of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.