NieR: Automata · 2017
NieR: Automata uses repetition itself to ask what makes a life worth living
NieR: Automata pairs PlatinumGames combat with Yoko Taro's philosophical storytelling, rewarding patience across multiple playthroughs and endings.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
NieR: Automata is an action game that often seems more interested in questions than in fights. What does it mean to have purpose? Can something built for war choose peace? Yoko Taro's writing takes these ideas seriously, and the game's unusual structure turns them into something players feel rather than merely read. It is one of the most distinctive games of its generation.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #34
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2017
- Released
- 9.6
- Best at: Story
That distinction comes with friction. The early hours can seem ordinary, and reaching the story's heart demands a commitment some players will not make.
The ruined Earth, with cities reclaimed by forests and deserts, is quietly beautiful and melancholy.
How it plays
PlatinumGames brings its signature responsiveness. 2B can combine light and heavy weapons, dodge at the last moment to trigger counterattacks, and rely on a floating Pod for ranged fire and special abilities. Encounters shift perspectives freely, moving from third-person brawling to side-scrolling platforming or top-down bullet-hell shooting, often within the same sequence. Plug-in chips allow players to customise abilities, from auto-healing to changes in the interface itself.
The combat is enjoyable rather than deep, particularly compared with Bayonetta or Metal Gear Rising, and on normal difficulty many fights are easy. Its purpose is momentum and spectacle, supporting a story that constantly changes register.
The structure is the boldest element. After the first ending, players begin again from a different point of view. Initially, this route replays much of the same ground, which is where many players falter, but it introduces new mechanics, fresh information and emotional context. Subsequent routes then move into entirely new territory, and the game's larger design only becomes clear with persistence.

World and story
The ruined Earth, with cities reclaimed by forests and deserts, is quietly beautiful and melancholy. It is also underpopulated, and side quests frequently devolve into fetching items or travelling long distances.
Yet those same quests contain some of the best writing. Machines forming communities, imitating human rituals or searching for meaning create small stories of comedy and tragedy that complicate the war at the centre. 2B and 9S have a restrained but affecting relationship, and the game handles philosophical themes with a mix of sincerity and mischievous self-awareness.
Presentation
The visual design is striking, particularly the YoRHa androids and the eerie architecture of certain machine locations, although textures and environments can look plain up close. Keiichi Okabe's score is the standout, with vocal tracks that swell and fade depending on the action, and it contributes enormously to the emotional impact. The original PC release was notoriously unstable, a problem later addressed in updated editions.
Who it is for
Players who value ambitious storytelling and are prepared to engage with multiple playthroughs will find NieR: Automata unforgettable. Those looking for purely combat-driven action, or who dislike repetition, may find the structure frustrating before its rewards arrive.
What works
- Later playthroughs recontextualise events rather than simply repeating them
- Fluid PlatinumGames combat with switchable weapons and Pod support
- Keiichi Okabe's haunting score shifts dynamically with the action
- Side stories about machines explore grief, faith and identity with real nuance
What doesn’t
- The second route replays much of the first with limited variation
- The open world is sparse and many side quests are simple fetch tasks
- Combat is shallower than the studio's dedicated action games
Head to head
- Story
- 9.69.0
- Gameplay
- 8.58.0
- Longevity
- 8.88.2
- Presentation
- 9.09.0
NieR: Automata edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
NieR: Automata uses its structure, music and wandering side stories to build something genuinely moving, and its thematic ambition remains rare in the medium. Repetitive early routes, a sparse world and relatively simple combat stop it short of perfection, but its story and score justify an exceptional rating.





