Palworld · 2024
Palworld: a derivative creature survival game that is dangerously fun anyway
Palworld mixes monster catching, base automation, crafting and firearms into a viral survival hit. Rough, borrowed and unfinished, yet hard to put down.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Palworld's reputation arrived before most people had played it. Nicknamed a monster-catching game with guns, it provoked curiosity, jokes and accusations of imitation in equal measure, then became a phenomenon within days of its early access release. The surprise was that beneath its provocative pitch lay a genuinely compulsive survival game.
- 7.3
- Editorial score
- #114
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 7.9
- Best at: Longevity
It is also rough, heavily derivative and clearly unfinished. Its appeal is less about originality than about how well it combines ideas players already love.
Palworld uses bright, colourful visuals and the Unreal Engine to create attractive landscapes, but polish is inconsistent.
How it plays
The structure borrows from survival crafting games. Players gather wood and stone, build shelters, unlock technology and gradually expand into more dangerous regions. What changes the formula is the Pals. Capturing creatures, by weakening them and then throwing a sphere, gives players companions that fight, carry and, crucially, work.
Bases become the core of the game. Pals assigned to a camp will chop trees, mine ore, water crops, cook, transport goods and craft items, each with skills that make them better suited to specific jobs. Watching a thriving base run itself is deeply satisfying, and it turns resource management from a solo chore into a system of creature-powered automation.
Pals are also essential for exploration. Some can be ridden, others enable gliding or swimming, and flying mounts make large distances manageable. Boss fights and towers provide progression milestones, and multiplayer adds considerable fun, especially in shared worlds.
The weaknesses are clear. Gunplay and melee lack weight, balance fluctuates, and the grind for higher-tier materials can become repetitive. Pathfinding for Pals at bases is often erratic, with creatures getting stuck or wandering off, and bugs and clipping are common.

World and tone
The Palpagos Islands are large and varied, moving from grasslands to volcanic regions and snowfields, though environments often look generic. There is little meaningful story, with scattered notes providing background.
The tone mixes cute creature designs with dark humour, including the ability to exploit Pals as labour or deploy them in grim ways. Some find this subversive and funny; others find it mean-spirited. Many of the Pal designs also closely resemble well-known creatures from other franchises, which has drawn persistent criticism and can be distracting. Nintendo has also brought a patent lawsuit against the studio.
Presentation
Palworld uses bright, colourful visuals and the Unreal Engine to create attractive landscapes, but polish is inconsistent. Animations can be stiff, interface design is functional, and performance varies depending on hardware and base size.
Who it is for
Players who enjoy survival crafting, base building and co-op sandbox chaos will likely find it compulsive. Those who value original creature design, tight combat or polish may find its borrowed ideas and early access state hard to overlook.
What works
- Putting captured creatures to work at bases makes automation delightfully tactile
- Pals double as mounts and gliders, making traversal varied and fun
- Co-op sessions produce chaotic, funny and memorable moments
- A steady stream of updates has added islands, Pals and systems
What doesn’t
- Many creature designs lean uncomfortably close to familiar monster series
- Pathfinding problems, bugs and clipping betray its early access state
- Combat and gunplay are loose, and the late game becomes a grind
Head to head
- Story
- 4.06.5
- Gameplay
- 7.89.2
- Longevity
- 7.99.6
- Presentation
- 6.88.7
Satisfactory edges it by 1.6. See them side by side
The verdict
Palworld succeeds by merging creature collection with survival crafting and automation, resulting in an addictive loop that is especially fun with friends. Its derivative designs, technical roughness and grindy later stages hold it back substantially, but its core ideas and sheer enjoyment still make it a good, if flawed, game.





