Project Hail Mary · 2021
Project Hail Mary: Andy Weir's problem-solving thriller finds a big, warm heart
Andy Weir's Project Hail Mary strands an amnesiac teacher on a mission to save the Sun. Clever, funny and moving, though its jokey voice will not suit all.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Project Hail Mary takes the formula that made The Martian a hit, a lone scientist solving one lethal problem after another with ingenuity and gallows humour, and expands it dramatically in scale and heart. What begins as a survival puzzle turns into something unexpectedly sweet: a story about friendship, courage and sacrifice that has become many readers' favourite of Andy Weir's novels.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #31
- Of 61 books reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 476
- Pages
The less a reader knows going in, the better. This review stays with the setup and the general shape of the book.
Stratt is a compelling figure, ruthless yet rational, and the moral questions around her decisions add welcome tension.
Science as suspense
Weir's great talent is making real-world scientific reasoning feel like a thriller. Grace wakes up disoriented and must work out basic facts, such as gravity, his location and his purpose, using simple experiments. Each discovery unlocks the next question, and the process is genuinely gripping. The larger mystery of the organism dimming the Sun, and how humanity might fight it, is plotted with inventive rigour.
The explanations are clear and pitched for general readers. However, they are also frequent and lengthy. Readers who relish the problem-solving will be delighted; those less interested in calculations and experimental method may start skimming.

A friendship across the void
Without revealing specifics, the book's middle is transformed by an encounter that introduces a second major character, and this relationship gives the story its emotional power. Weir builds it with patience and humour, making communication itself a scientific and human challenge. It is the most imaginative thing he has written, and the source of the book's most memorable moments.
Grace himself is an appealing everyman, likeable and self-deprecating, though his wisecracking voice is very close to Mark Watney's in The Martian. The jokes, exclamations and pop-culture references can grate, especially at emotionally significant moments. The book's structure, which lets memories surface when the plot needs them, is sometimes convenient, but it also allows Weir to reveal difficult truths about Grace's past and character.
The mission's origins
Flashback chapters show the global effort to create the Hail Mary, overseen by Eva Stratt, an administrator granted near-absolute authority to save the planet. Stratt is a compelling figure, ruthless yet rational, and the moral questions around her decisions add welcome tension. Other Earth characters, including scientists and officials, remain sketchy, and the political implications of a planet facing catastrophe are handled briskly.
Who it is for
It is ideal for readers who enjoyed The Martian, fans of hard science fiction with an optimistic outlook and anyone looking for an accessible, crowd-pleasing adventure. Those who dislike humour in serious situations or who prefer literary prose may find the voice too casual. It is also a good choice for younger adult readers interested in science.
What works
- Scientific puzzles are explained clearly and make the plot exciting
- An unexpected central friendship is funny, touching and inventive
- The amnesia structure gradually uncovers vital secrets in the flashbacks
- Much warmer and more emotionally ambitious than The Martian
What doesn’t
- Grace's relentless quips can feel juvenile and grating
- Long passages of scientific exposition slow the momentum
- Earth-bound characters beyond Eva Stratt are thinly sketched
Head to head
- Ideas
- 8.98.3
- Story
- 8.97.1
- Writing
- 7.38.6
- Characters
- 8.47.9
Project Hail Mary edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
Project Hail Mary is an exceptionally entertaining novel that combines clever scientific problem-solving with genuine emotional warmth. Its prose is plain, its humour can be grating and its exposition is heavy, but its inventiveness and heart outweigh those flaws comfortably. It is Weir's most satisfying book to date and an excellent example of optimistic, puzzle-driven science fiction.



