Skip to content

Head to head

Klara and the Sun vs Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary takes it by 0.8, 8.6 against 7.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Klara and the Sun
Klara and the Sun

2021 · Good

  • Klara's precise, innocent perspective is a striking narrative achievement
  • Her faith in the Sun is both touching and quietly heartbreaking
  • Its world stays so vague that some themes feel under-explored
Cover of Project Hail Mary
Project Hail Mary

2021 · Excellent

  • Scientific puzzles are explained clearly and make the plot exciting
  • An unexpected central friendship is funny, touching and inventive
  • Grace's relentless quips can feel juvenile and grating

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.38.9
Story
7.18.9
Writing
8.67.3
Characters
7.98.4

At a glance

FactKlara and the SunProject Hail Mary
Released2 March 20214 May 2021
AuthorKazuo IshiguroAndy Weir
PublisherFaber and FaberBallantine Books
Pages307476
GenreSci-Fi · Literary fictionSci-Fi

The two verdicts

Klara and the Sun

Klara and the Sun: Ishiguro's gentle machine narrator asks what love is made of

Klara and the Sun is a graceful, humane novel with a narrator who lingers in the memory long after the final page. Its vagueness about the world, its muted tone and its similarity to Ishiguro's earlier triumph keep it from ranking among his very best. It is still a good and thoughtful book, and a quietly moving one.

Read the full review →

Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary: Andy Weir's problem-solving thriller finds a big, warm heart

Project Hail Mary is an exceptionally entertaining novel that combines clever scientific problem-solving with genuine emotional warmth. Its prose is plain, its humour can be grating and its exposition is heavy, but its inventiveness and heart outweigh those flaws comfortably. It is Weir's most satisfying book to date and an excellent example of optimistic, puzzle-driven science fiction.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.