Returnal · 2021
Returnal fuses bullet-hell intensity with a haunting psychological mystery
Returnal traps Selene in a looping alien nightmare, pairing Housemarque's arcade-perfect shooting with punishing roguelike runs and unsettling horror.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Returnal is Housemarque's leap from arcade shooters into big-budget, story-led design, and it retains the studio's greatest strength: combat that feels immaculate. What surrounds it is a dense, unsettling mystery and a roguelike structure that can be merciless. The result is one of the PlayStation 5's most distinctive early exclusives, and one of its most demanding.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #76
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Gameplay
It rewards patience and persistence richly, but it never makes that easy.
The result is one of the PlayStation 5's most distinctive early exclusives, and one of its most demanding.
How it plays
Combat is fast and fluid. Enemies fill the air with glowing projectiles in patterns reminiscent of classic arcade shooters, while Selene dashes through attacks, uses melee to break shields and fires weapons with unlockable traits. Mastery comes from learning enemy behaviour, reading bullet patterns and managing adrenaline, which rewards avoiding damage with increasing bonuses.
The roguelike systems add risk to every decision. Parasites offer benefits with drawbacks, malignant items may cause malfunctions, and consumables and artefacts shape a run's build. Some upgrades are permanent, such as traversal tools that unlock new areas, but most progress resets on death.
This is where the design becomes contentious. Runs can be long, and at launch there was no way to suspend a session and resume it later, making each death costly. Housemarque later added the ability to suspend cycles, which alleviates the problem without softening the difficulty. Randomness can also be punishing, with some runs offering weak weapons or harsh parasites.

World and story
Atropos is a hostile, shifting world, moving from overgrown ruins and red deserts to derelict cities and deeper, stranger places. Rooms rearrange between runs, but the biomes' overall structure remains, which becomes familiar over time.
The narrative is a highlight. Selene discovers recordings of her own voice, strange monuments and a house that should not exist, with first-person sequences that shift the game into psychological horror. The story is ambiguous and demands attention, rewarding those who piece together its hints and themes of trauma, guilt and repetition.
Presentation
Returnal is visually striking, particularly in its lighting, particle effects and the dense spectacle of combat. Sound design is exceptional, with 3D audio helping players track threats and Bobby Krlic's unnerving score adding tension. The DualSense controller is used intelligently, with adaptive triggers for alternate fire and haptic feedback that conveys rain and impacts.
Later updates added co-op and a separate endless mode, extending the game's life for committed players.
Who it is for
Players who enjoy challenging shooters, roguelikes or ambiguous psychological stories should find Returnal gripping. Those who prefer steady progression or dislike losing progress should be aware of its uncompromising design.
What works
- Fast, readable bullet-hell combat with precise dashing and weapon traits
- Parasites and malignant items make every run a gamble of risk and reward
- An eerie, ambiguous story told through audio logs and unsettling interludes
- Superb sound design and use of controller haptics heighten tension
What doesn’t
- Long runs without saving at launch made failure unusually costly
- Steep difficulty and heavy randomness can make progress feel arbitrary
- Biome structure grows familiar across repeated cycles
Head to head
- Story
- 8.39.3
- Gameplay
- 9.29.5
- Longevity
- 7.89.2
- Presentation
- 9.19.3
Hades edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
Returnal combines exceptional combat, an intriguing and unsettling story, and technically impressive presentation into a bold, uncompromising roguelike. Its harsh difficulty and the swing of randomness will always divide players, and the biome structure wears thin on repeat cycles. For those who accept its terms, few shooters feel this exhilarating or leave such a lingering sense of unease.





