Scott Pilgrim · 2004
Scott Pilgrim: a slacker romance drawn like a boss fight, and wiser than it looks
Scott Pilgrim review. Bryan Lee O'Malley's six Oni Press volumes turn a Toronto twenty-something's love life into video-game duels, and grow up along the way.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Scott Pilgrim looks like a joke that ran for six books. A twenty-three-year-old bassist who does nothing all day falls for a girl who roller-skates through his dreams, and to keep her he has to fight her exes one by one, each defeat paying out in loose change like a sprite in an arcade game. The surprise is how much of the series is not about the fights. Bryan Lee O'Malley built a comedy about being young and useless in Toronto, then spent six years making his hero face what kind of boyfriend, friend and ex he has actually been.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #26
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2004
- Released
- 9.0
- Best at: Art
That turn is what separates it from the many comics it influenced. The video-game grammar, the manga speed lines, the indie-rock in-jokes are all there and all funny. But by the later volumes the gags are holding up something sturdier: a story about memory, and about how people edit their own pasts to stay the hero of them.
The premise
Scott Pilgrim lives in a cheap flat with his roommate Wallace Wells, shares Wallace's bed because he owns almost nothing, and plays bass in Sex Bob-omb, a garage band with more enthusiasm than songs. He is dating Knives Chau, a seventeen-year-old schoolgirl whose idea of a date is watching the band rehearse, and his friends are united in thinking this is a bad idea. Then Ramona Flowers appears, first in his dreams and then at a party, and Scott decides with the logic of a teenager that he must go out with her.
The catch arrives at a battle of the bands. Ramona has seven evil exes, organised into a league, and each one intends to stop anyone else from dating her. What follows is a structure as plain as a level select screen: one ex per stretch of story, with life going on around the fights. O'Malley plays it absolutely straight. Nobody in Toronto finds it odd that a man can crash through a ceiling mid-gig, and that deadpan acceptance is where most of the comedy lives.
2004
Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life, the first volume, published by Oni Press in August
2006
The third volume follows; O'Malley wins the Joe Shuster Award for Canadian cartoonists
2010
Volume five wins the Eisner for Best Humor Publication; the sixth and last arrives in July, weeks before the film
2012
Colour hardcovers, coloured by Nathan Fairbairn, begin and run until 2015
2023
Netflix releases Scott Pilgrim Takes Off, written with O'Malley
2024
Oni Press marks twenty years with new hardcover box sets in colour and black and white

The writing
O'Malley writes dialogue the way people in their early twenties talk when they think nobody is keeping score: fast, evasive, full of in-jokes and half-finished sentences. Captions introduce characters with their age and a game-style rating, so that the narration itself becomes a running gag. A lot of the best jokes are visual, but the wordplay holds up on its own, particularly Wallace's flat one-liners, which puncture Scott's self-pity more efficiently than any fight.
The cleverer thing is that the comedy carries the argument. Scott's memory is unreliable in a way the books treat as a joke at first: he cannot remember how his old relationships ended, and the narration takes his word for it. As the series goes on, other characters start correcting the record, and the reader realises that the hero's version of events has been the least trustworthy thing on the page all along. The series earns its seriousness by planting it in gags rather than announcing it.
A comedy about a man who keeps fighting his girlfriend's past, written so that his own catches up with him.
The art
O'Malley has said he set out to make something closer to Japanese shōnen comics than to American superhero books, with Ranma ½ as the strongest model, and he chose black and white partly because it was cheaper. Both decisions shaped the look. The first volume is loose and rubbery, with large heads, minimal backgrounds and computer-built screentone. The fights borrow the full-bleed, exploding layouts he admired in manga, and they move: a punch travels across a spread, and the panel borders seem to give way under it.
What makes the run worth reading in order is how far the drawing travels. By the fourth volume the line is tighter, the faces more expressive with fewer marks, and the city has started to fill in. O'Malley took on two assistants for the final book, and its backgrounds are noticeably richer. Through all of it the cartooning stays legible on the small digest page, which is harder than it looks when a scene has six characters, a band and an explosion in it.
| Volume | Title | First published |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life | August 2004 |
| 2 | Scott Pilgrim vs. the World | June 2005 |
| 3 | Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness | May 2006 |
| 4 | Scott Pilgrim Gets It Together | November 2007 |
| 5 | Scott Pilgrim vs. the Universe | February 2009 |
| 6 | Scott Pilgrim's Finest Hour | July 2010 |
Characters
Scott is a hard lead to love in the first two books, and that is the point. He is careless with Knives, oblivious to Kim, and convinced that the world owes him a happy ending because he has decided he wants one. The series lets other people see this before he does. Kim Pine, Sex Bob-omb's drummer and Scott's ex from school, says more with a glare than most characters manage in a speech, and she becomes the moral centre of the books without ever being given a big moment to announce it.
Ramona is drawn with deliberate distance early on. She changes her hair colour constantly, deflects every question about her past and is clearly hiding something; the books let her stay a little opaque, which some readers find frustrating and others find honest. Knives, meanwhile, starts as the joke of the first volume and turns into one of its most sympathetic people. Wallace, Stephen Stills and Young Neil fill in a social circle that feels lived in, the kind of friends who will mock a disaster before they help with it.
The city is a character too. Lee's Palace, Honest Ed's, Casa Loma and the Toronto Reference Library all appear as themselves, and much of the comedy depends on placing absurd violence in very ordinary Canadian rooms.
Pacing and format
The digest format, roughly the size of a manga paperback, suits the story's rhythm: quick pages, lots of white space, gags that land on a page turn. The early volumes are breezy and episodic, a fight bookended by band practice and bad dates. The middle books slow down to let relationships breathe, and the fourth is where many readers decide the series is more than a novelty.
The pace is less sure-footed at the end. O'Malley has described the fifth volume as the darkest hour and the sixth as the redemption, and he has said openly that he finds parts of the finale weaker than the rest. Without giving anything away, the mystical explanation behind the league is the thread that gets the least room, and the final book has a great deal to resolve in its pages. The emotional ending works better than the plot one.
How it reads
- Comedy
- 9/10
- Dense with sight gags, captions and Wallace's asides
- Action clarity
- 8.5/10
- Fights read cleanly even at digest size
- Emotional weight
- 7.5/10
- Light at first, considerably heavier by the later volumes
- Plot coherence
- 6.5/10
- The relationships hold together better than the mythology
Where to start
There is only one place to begin: the first volume, Scott Pilgrim's Precious Little Life. The question is which edition. The original black-and-white digests are the books as O'Malley drew them, cheap and portable. The colour hardcovers, coloured by Nathan Fairbairn between 2012 and 2015, add warmth and some bonus material, and the 2019 Color Collection gathers them into three larger paperbacks. The 2024 anniversary box sets come in both versions.
Anyone who has seen the 2010 film already knows the shape of the first act, but the books spend much more time between the fights and treat the supporting cast with more patience. Readers who arrived through the animated series will find its starting point here; our review of Scott Pilgrim Takes Off looks at what it changes.
The two make a good pair: the comic as the source text and the series as an argument with it, written by the same author nearly twenty years apart.
For you if
- Readers who like romantic comedy with a strange streak running through it
- Anyone who grew up on cartridge games, indie gigs and manga paperbacks
- Fans of the film who want the slower, kinder version of the story
Not for you if
- Readers who need a likeable hero from the first page
- Anyone who wants a tight, fully explained plot rather than a story about feelings
- Readers allergic to video-game references and in-jokes
For a reader who has never opened one of these books, the whole decision rests on the first volume, which is short and quick.
What works
- Fights drawn with the clarity of a manga action page and the logic of a cartridge game
- A Toronto of real bars, libraries and shops that the jokes are built around
- Kim Pine, Wallace Wells and Knives Chau each outgrow their first-volume punchlines
- The drawing visibly sharpens volume by volume, and the later books are denser for it
What doesn’t
- Scott is hard company for the first two volumes, by design but at a cost
- The supernatural machinery of the final volumes is the weakest thread in the story
- Six years between first and last book show in uneven pacing across the run
The verdict
Scott Pilgrim earns its reputation by being two things at once: a fast, funny comic about punching people in Toronto, and a slow-building story about a young man learning that his memory flatters him. The art grows up alongside its hero, the supporting cast is drawn with real affection, and the fights remain some of the most readable action in Western comics of the period. It falls short of the top tier because the plot machinery of the final stretch is thinner than the emotions it carries, and because the early volumes ask readers to put up with Scott before they understand why. Those are the costs of a series made over six years by a cartoonist working out what it was about. The result is still one of the defining comics of its decade.





