Sea of Stars · 2023
Sea of Stars is a gorgeous love letter to the SNES RPG that plays it safe
Sea of Stars revives the 16-bit JRPG with lush pixel art, timed-hit combat and clever puzzles. A beautiful homage with a story that rarely matches its looks.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Sea of Stars is openly nostalgic. It evokes the look, rhythm and warmth of the SNES era of role-playing games, especially Chrono Trigger, while adding the conveniences and visual effects that modern players expect. It is exceptionally pretty and consistently pleasant to play, and many will find it a comforting adventure.
- 8.2
- Editorial score
- #93
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Presentation
Where it falls short is ambition. The story and systems rarely step beyond competent homage, and its protagonists never quite come into focus.
The story and systems rarely step beyond competent homage, and its protagonists never quite come into focus.
How it plays
Combat is turn-based but active. Pressing a button at the right moment boosts attacks or reduces incoming damage, keeping players attentive. When enemies prepare powerful moves, a set of locks appears above them, showing the damage types needed to interrupt. Choosing which characters to use and in what order becomes a small puzzle each turn. Combo attacks and live mana, which strengthens regular abilities, add further options.
There are no random encounters; enemies are visible in the world, and battles take place where they are found. This helps pacing considerably. However, progression is limited. Characters gain levels and choose small stat bonuses, but there are few ways to customise abilities or roles, so combat can feel repetitive in longer dungeons.
Exploration is a highlight. Characters can climb, jump gaps and swim, and dungeons include environmental puzzles using light, shadows and switches. Relics serve as accessibility options, allowing players to make combat easier or harder.
Side activities include cooking, fishing and a surprisingly deep tabletop game called Wheels.

World and story
The world is full of charming locations: fishing villages, haunted mansions, pirate ships and mystical islands. Garl is the emotional heart, a warm and humble companion whose optimism brightens every scene.
Zale and Valere, however, are more bland than they should be, and the narrative's early promise gives way to a middle section that wanders. Later developments broaden the scope, and fans of The Messenger will spot connections, but pacing and characterisation are uneven.
Presentation
The pixel art is outstanding, with rich colours, detailed animations and dynamic lighting effects that shift through day and night. Few games in this style look as polished.
The soundtrack, primarily composed by Eric W. Brown with guest contributions from Yasunori Mitsuda, blends adventurous melodies with atmospheric pieces and complements the nostalgic aesthetic, although it can be less memorable than the classics that inspired it.
Who it is for
Fans of classic JRPGs and anyone drawn to pixel art will likely find Sea of Stars delightful. Players seeking complex customisation or a narrative that pushes boundaries may find it too conservative.
What works
- Exquisite pixel art with dynamic lighting that makes every area glow
- Lock-breaking and timed hits keep turn-based fights engaged
- Traversal puzzles and climbing make exploration more active than its inspirations
- Optional relics let players tailor difficulty without shame
What doesn’t
- The two leads are thinly written compared with the supporting cast
- Character progression is shallow, with limited build choices
- The middle and late story meander before the pay-off
Head to head
- Story
- 7.29.3
- Gameplay
- 8.49.4
- Longevity
- 7.59.7
- Presentation
- 9.48.9
Baldur's Gate 3 edges it by 1.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Sea of Stars delivers a gorgeous, well-paced homage to 16-bit role-playing games, with engaging combat mechanics, thoughtful exploration and a lovable supporting cast. Shallow progression, flat protagonists and a wandering midsection keep it below the classics it honours. As a lovingly made, beautifully presented tribute that respects players' time, it is still very easy to recommend to anyone who grew up on 16-bit RPGs.





