Stardew Valley · 2016
Stardew Valley is a gentle farming life sim with a remarkably big heart
Stardew Valley blends farming, fishing, mining and village friendships into a cosy, deep and generous life sim, built by one developer and still growing.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Stardew Valley is a game about slowing down, but it is rarely boring. Inspired by the Harvest Moon series, it builds a world of seasonal routines, small goals and gradual progress that becomes deeply absorbing. It is also a remarkable example of what a single dedicated developer can create, and it has become one of the most beloved independent games ever made.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #34
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2016
- Released
- 9.7
- Best at: Longevity
Its success lies in how naturally its many systems fit together.
Building friendships through gifts and conversation reveals these stories gradually, and several are surprisingly affecting.
How it plays
Days are short and structured by energy and time. Players water crops, tend animals, fish in rivers and lakes, forage for seasonal items and venture into mines to find ore and gems. Early on, energy limits and basic tools can make progress slow. As upgrades arrive, the farm expands, automation such as sprinklers frees up time, and days become more ambitious.
The variety of activities means there is always something to do. Crafting and building allow players to customise their farms. The community centre bundles provide clear goals, encouraging players to collect items from every system. Festivals mark the passing of seasons.
Fishing uses a bar-balancing mini-game that many find satisfying but others find frustrating. Combat in the mines is straightforward, relying on basic weapons and timing, and later areas offer more challenge without much depth.
There is no real failure. Crops can wither and days can be wasted, but players can progress at their own pace.

World and story
Pelican Town is the heart of the game. Its residents have routines, personalities and stories, many dealing with loneliness, family problems, career disappointments and personal struggles. Building friendships through gifts and conversation reveals these stories gradually, and several are surprisingly affecting.
Romance options allow marriage and children, though relationships after marriage can feel less developed. The central conflict, choosing between restoring the community centre or supporting the corporate Joja Mart, is simple but carries a clear message about community.
Later updates added new areas, including an island region, along with extra events, items and quality-of-life features, making the game significantly larger than at launch.
Presentation
The pixel art is warm and detailed, with seasonal changes transforming the landscape. Character portraits are expressive, and animations are charming. Barone also composed the soundtrack, which offers calm, memorable seasonal themes that suit long play sessions.
The interface is functional but can feel cluttered, particularly inventory management.
Who it is for
Players seeking relaxing, long-term games will find it ideal, especially those who enjoy farming or life simulations. Co-op makes it a great shared experience. Those who prefer fast action or intense challenges may find it too gentle.
What works
- A wonderfully balanced loop of farming, fishing, mining and socialising
- Pelican Town's residents have surprisingly thoughtful personal stories
- Freedom to play at any pace, with no punishing failure states
- Years of free updates have added a vast amount of content
What doesn’t
- Early energy limits and slow tools make the first days sluggish
- The fishing mini-game is frustrating for many players
- Combat in the mines is simple and rarely exciting
Head to head
- Story
- 8.09.8
- Gameplay
- 9.28.9
- Longevity
- 9.79.0
- Presentation
- 8.49.2
Disco Elysium edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Stardew Valley combines farming, exploration and social storytelling into a rich, rewarding and consistently charming experience that has only grown over time. A sluggish opening, fussy fishing and basic combat are the only real blemishes. Beyond them lies one of the most generous, humane games of its kind, still expanding years after release and still setting the standard for the farming life sim.





