Starfield · 2023
Starfield: a vast Bethesda universe that too often feels far away
Starfield brings Bethesda's RPG formula to space with strong faction quests and deep ship building, but fragmented exploration holds its universe back.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Starfield is Bethesda Game Studios attempting its biggest leap: taking the open-ended structure of The Elder Scrolls and Fallout into the stars. The result contains many of the studio's strengths, including memorable quests, deep customisation and a sense of freedom. But the scale that defines it also undermines it, turning exploration into a series of disconnected destinations rather than a seamless world.
- 7.2
- Editorial score
- #115
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 8.2
- Best at: Longevity
It is a good game with remarkable moments, but rarely the transformative experience its premise suggests.
Companions, while varied, lack the charm of the studio's best characters.
How it plays
Combat is the best in any Bethesda game. Gunplay is responsive, weapons feel distinct, and low-gravity environments add a playful dimension. Stealth, persuasion and skill-based approaches offer alternatives.
The ship builder is a standout. Players can design vessels from modular parts, balancing weight, power and firepower while creating striking custom designs. Space combat is serviceable, although dogfights can feel simple.
Outposts allow players to build bases and resource extraction networks, but the system is complex and often poorly explained, offering limited reward for many players.
Exploration is where Starfield falters. Travel usually consists of menus, fast travel and loading screens, moving from planet to orbit to another system. Landing on a planet places players in a limited area, where procedurally placed structures and resources can repeat quickly. The feeling of stumbling upon something unexpected, central to Bethesda's earlier games, is diluted.

World and story
The Settled Systems have a grounded, NASA-punk aesthetic with practical spacecraft and functional architecture. Cities such as New Atlantis and Neon provide distinct styles, from polished capital to neon-lit pleasure hub.
The main story begins with a mystery about artefacts and builds towards unusual ideas, but pacing is uneven and characters often feel flat. Companions, while varied, lack the charm of the studio's best characters.
Faction questlines are much stronger. Working undercover in a corporation, joining the Freestar Rangers or dealing with the pirate Crimson Fleet produces some of the most engaging content in the game, with choices and consequences that feel meaningful.
Presentation
Starfield can be visually impressive, especially in handcrafted locations, with detailed interiors and dramatic planetary vistas. Lighting and art direction give it a distinct identity. However, character animation and facial expressions are inconsistent, and procedural environments can look bland.
Inon Zur's orchestral score captures a sense of wonder, even when exploration does not.
Post-launch updates have added improvements such as surface vehicles and more detailed maps, addressing some complaints.
Who it is for
Bethesda fans who enjoy creating characters, pursuing factions and customising ships may find hundreds of hours of content. Those seeking seamless exploration or a strong main narrative may find it disappointing.
What works
- Faction questlines, especially the corporate espionage arc, are highly memorable
- Deep ship builder allows creative and functional custom vessels
- A grounded NASA-inspired aesthetic gives the setting a distinct identity
- Satisfying gunplay by Bethesda standards, with low-gravity combat
What doesn’t
- Menus and loading screens fragment exploration and break immersion
- Procedural planets are often empty and repetitive
- Companions and main story lack the spark of the studio's best work
Head to head
- Story
- 6.99.0
- Gameplay
- 7.48.0
- Longevity
- 8.28.2
- Presentation
- 7.69.0
Cyberpunk 2077 edges it by 0.9. See them side by side
The verdict
Starfield offers strong faction quests, satisfying combat and a superb ship builder, making it a good space RPG. However, fragmented exploration, repetitive procedural planets and a lacklustre main story prevent it from reaching the heights of Bethesda's best, earning it a good but notably flawed score.





