The Boys · 2019
The Boys: a gleefully vicious superhero satire that sometimes mistakes shock for insight
The Boys review: Eric Kripke's Prime Video satire skewers celebrity superheroes with gore and dark wit, led by Antony Starr's terrifying Homelander.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Boys starts from an irresistible question: what if the people with godlike powers behaved like the worst celebrities, protected by marketing departments and legal teams? Eric Kripke's series answers with a blend of black comedy, graphic violence and pointed satire that felt genuinely fresh when it arrived in 2019, in the thick of the superhero boom.
- 8.0
- Editorial score
- #62
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
Its best seasons are thrilling and frequently hilarious. Over time, though, the show's appetite for outrageousness and its increasingly direct political commentary have made it feel less sharp than loud.
Its fake Vought advertisements, cinematic tie-ins and branded content are a clever source of world-building and humour.
Story
The first season is lean and propulsive. Hughie, a mild-mannered electronics salesman, is drawn into Butcher's crusade after a personal tragedy caused by a careless superhero, and the story alternates between the vigilantes' scrappy schemes and the corporate rot inside Vought. The second and third seasons expand the world, introducing new heroes and deepening the mythology, with some of the show's most memorable episodes.
The fourth season drew more mixed reactions. Its focus on political extremism and online radicalisation is timely, but the plotting often feels as if it is treading water, with major confrontations delayed and characters repeating similar arcs. The show's commitment to topping its own shock moments also begins to produce diminishing returns.

Characters and performances
Antony Starr's Homelander is the defining creation of the series. He plays a figure of limitless power with the emotional needs of a neglected child, and the flickers between a practised smile and naked menace are genuinely chilling. Karl Urban's Butcher is a foul-mouthed, obsessive antihero whose ruthlessness is both entertaining and troubling, while Jack Quaid gives Hughie a nervy decency that makes him an effective audience surrogate.
Erin Moriarty's Starlight offers an idealistic view from inside the Seven, and Laz Alonso's Mother's Milk and Karen Fukuhara's silent, formidable Kimiko add warmth and depth to the team. Chace Crawford's The Deep and Jessie T. Usher's A-Train provide satirical portraits of fame's absurdities, and guest additions such as Aya Cash and Jensen Ackles bring memorable energy to later seasons.
Craft and tone
The Boys is an expensive-looking show, with convincing superpower effects that are used as much for gruesome comedy as for spectacle. Its fake Vought advertisements, cinematic tie-ins and branded content are a clever source of world-building and humour. The show's darkly comic tone is its signature, but it can make genuine emotion hard to sustain when a scene of real pain is followed immediately by a gag involving body horror.
Who it is for
This is strictly adult viewing, with extreme violence, nudity and crude humour throughout. It suits viewers tired of polished superhero franchises who want something irreverent and angry. Fans of the genre who find cynicism wearing may prefer something warmer, and anyone squeamish should steer clear.
What works
- Antony Starr's Homelander is one of television's most frightening villains
- Satire of corporate branding and celebrity culture hits hard and often
- Karl Urban and Jack Quaid make a spiky, entertaining central pairing
- Unpredictable, inventive set pieces keep viewers genuinely off balance
What doesn’t
- Escalating gross-out moments become repetitive rather than shocking
- Later seasons stall, with characters stuck in familiar holding patterns
- Political satire grows increasingly blunt and less nuanced
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.19.0
- Story
- 7.67.0
- Characters
- 8.37.6
- Performances
- 8.87.4
The Boys edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
The Boys has been one of the most distinctive superhero series of its era, with a towering villain, sharp early satire and an excellent cast. Its later seasons are messier, more repetitive and less subtle, even as they remain entertaining. An 8.0 reflects a bold, often brilliant series that has occasionally let excess do the work of ideas.





