The Mandalorian · 2019
The Mandalorian: a lean space western that rediscovered the fun of Star Wars
The Mandalorian review: Jon Favreau's Disney+ series brought Star Wars back to its pulpy roots with a masked hero and Grogu, before a weaker third season.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
When The Mandalorian launched alongside Disney+ in 2019, Star Wars was in a strange place, with its film saga stirring as much fan argument as enthusiasm. Jon Favreau's series offered something simpler: a lone gunslinger, a dusty frontier, and a small green child who melted hearts across the internet. It captured the pulpy, lived-in texture of the original trilogy more successfully than many of the franchise's films.
- 7.6
- Editorial score
- #80
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 3
- Seasons
The first two seasons are among the most enjoyable Star Wars stories of the modern era. The third, however, shifted focus in ways that diluted the show's appeal.
Ludwig Göransson's score, built around a haunting recorder melody and driving percussion, is instantly recognisable.
Story
The series was openly influenced by westerns and samurai films, particularly stories of warriors escorting children through dangerous territory. Early episodes follow a familiar rhythm: arrive on a planet, take a job, get into trouble, escape. That episodic structure is refreshingly unpretentious, allowing different directors, including Dave Filoni, Bryce Dallas Howard and Taika Waititi, to give episodes their own flavour.
The second season deepens the mythology, introducing figures from animated Star Wars series and building to an exhilarating finale. The third season, however, increasingly focuses on Mandalorian politics and supporting characters, sometimes sidelining Din Djarin in his own show. Its episodes feel less coherent, and viewers who had not followed related series, including The Book of Boba Fett, could find its connective tissue confusing.

Characters and performances
Pedro Pascal brings a gravelly weariness to Din Djarin's voice, and the character's strict code of never removing his helmet gives him an intriguing mystique. The trade-off is that much of the performance is conveyed through voice and body language, often by stunt performers, which limits the emotional intimacy of key scenes.
Grogu, initially known as the Child, is a triumph of puppetry and animatronics, and the growing bond between the hunter and his ward is the series' emotional core. Carl Weathers is warm and charismatic as Greef Karga, and Giancarlo Esposito lends silky menace to Moff Gideon. Werner Herzog's eccentric client in the first season is a memorable oddity, while Katee Sackhoff's Bo-Katan becomes more central over time.
Craft
The Mandalorian's technical achievements are significant. Industrial Light and Magic's StageCraft technology, using vast LED screens to display digital environments in real time, allowed the production to create convincing landscapes on a soundstage and influenced filmmaking far beyond Star Wars. Practical creatures, detailed costumes and weathered props recall the tactile appeal of the original films. Ludwig Göransson's score, built around a haunting recorder melody and driving percussion, is instantly recognisable.
Who it is for
The Mandalorian is ideal for Star Wars fans who enjoy the franchise's classic, adventurous side, and accessible to newcomers who like westerns and episodic adventures. Those seeking complex characters or tightly plotted serialised storytelling may find it lightweight, particularly in the third season.
What works
- A simple, episodic western structure makes early seasons irresistibly fun
- Grogu is an adorable creation that the show uses with genuine warmth
- Ludwig Göransson's score gives the series a distinct musical identity
- Pioneering LED volume sets deliver convincing alien worlds
What doesn’t
- The third season loses focus and relies on franchise mythology
- Side-quest episodes can feel like filler that pads each season
- A masked lead limits the emotional range of the central performance
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.08.1
- Story
- 7.07.6
- Characters
- 7.68.3
- Performances
- 7.48.8
The Boys edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
The Mandalorian delivered a charming, beautifully crafted revival of Star Wars storytelling, with a memorable duo at its heart. Its reliance on filler, limited character depth and a disappointing third season temper its achievements. A 7.6 reflects a good series with an excellent first half that lost some of its way.




