The Brutalist · 2024
The Brutalist: a monumental immigrant epic that cracks in its upper floors
The Brutalist review: Brady Corbet's post-war epic of a Hungarian architect in America is grand and ambitious, with a superb Adrien Brody at its core.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Brutalist is a film of rare scale and ambition: a sprawling, novelistic story of a fictional architect's struggle to build a life and a legacy in post-war America. Made on a modest budget but shot on large-format VistaVision cameras, it has the look and heft of a classic Hollywood epic. Its first half is exceptional, and its lead performance is one of the most powerful in recent years.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #80
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Craft
Its second half, however, loses some of that control. Brady Corbet's film is gripping, but its reach sometimes exceeds its grasp, particularly as it strains to bring its many themes to a conclusion.
Van Buren admires Laszlo's genius, offers him status and resources, but never lets him forget who holds the power.
Story
The film opens with Laszlo Toth emerging from the hold of a ship to see the Statue of Liberty appear upside down, an image that sets the tone for a story in which the American dream is always slightly askew. He stays with his cousin Attila in Philadelphia, but tensions push him out. When a commission from Van Buren's son goes wrong, then unexpectedly right, the tycoon takes an interest and offers Laszlo a huge project: a community centre on a hill near his estate.
The central relationship between artist and patron is fascinating. Van Buren admires Laszlo's genius, offers him status and resources, but never lets him forget who holds the power. When Erzsebet finally joins her husband, now using a wheelchair after her own wartime suffering, their marriage becomes another focus. The first part of the story, patient and absorbing, is stronger. After the intermission, events accelerate, some developments feel compressed, and the film's critiques of capitalism and antisemitism become increasingly blunt. A late, shocking act of cruelty and the closing epilogue both divided viewers.

Direction and craft
Corbet directs with confidence and a strong sense of style. Lol Crawley's photography is striking, capturing rain-soaked Philadelphia streets, sun-baked construction sites and dramatic marble quarries in Italy. The architecture itself, built from stark concrete, becomes a visual expression of Laszlo's trauma and resilience.
Daniel Blumberg's score is propulsive and unusual, full of hammering piano and brass that suggest both industry and anxiety. The intermission lends the film a sense of occasion, and the editing makes the long running time pass more easily than one might expect, at least in the first half.
Performances
Adrien Brody, who won the Academy Award for Best Actor for the role, gives Laszlo a mixture of pride, fragility and fierce conviction. He conveys the character's addiction, his trauma and his uncompromising artistic vision without falling into cliche. His accented English and moments of Hungarian feel natural.
Guy Pearce is superb as Van Buren, charming and expansive one moment and chillingly contemptuous the next. Felicity Jones has a demanding role as Erzsebet and brings intelligence and steel to it, although the character arrives late and has less space to develop. Joe Alwyn is effective as Van Buren's resentful son, while Alessandro Nivola, Isaach de Bankole and Raffey Cassidy make strong impressions in underwritten parts.
Who it is for
The Brutalist is for viewers who love grand, serious historical drama and films about art, immigration and power. Its length and themes require commitment, and it contains drug use, sexual content and a disturbing scene of sexual violence. Anyone expecting a conventional biopic should note that Laszlo is a fictional character.
What works
- Adrien Brody gives a raw, commanding portrait of ambition and trauma
- Guy Pearce is magnetic as a patron whose generosity masks contempt
- Grand VistaVision photography gives the film a classic epic scale
- Tackles immigration, antisemitism and art with serious ambition
What doesn’t
- The second half becomes rushed and more heavy-handed than the first
- The long running time exposes some thinly developed supporting roles
- A divisive epilogue changes the tone and meaning abruptly
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.27.6
- Story
- 7.65.6
- Direction
- 8.67.0
- Performances
- 8.97.2
The Brutalist edges it by 1.7. See them side by side
The verdict
The Brutalist is an audacious, handsomely made epic with outstanding lead performances and a brilliant first half, and it earned major awards recognition. Its uneven, heavy-handed second half and divisive ending keep it from masterpiece status, but its ambition and craft make it a significant and often gripping achievement.





