Gladiator II · 2024
Gladiator II: louder, bloodier and far less memorable than the original
Gladiator II review: Ridley Scott's sequel offers lavish spectacle and a relishable Denzel Washington, but largely replays the 2000 epic with less heart.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
Gladiator II had a great deal to live up to, and in trying to honour the original it mostly repeats it. Ridley Scott, still a formidable director of large-scale action in his eighties, delivers impressive spectacle and a few enjoyable performances, but the film's story is a remix of the 2000 epic with bigger crowds, stranger animals and considerably less emotional clarity. Critical reception was mixed, with praise for the craft and Denzel Washington tempered by widespread complaints about its derivative plot.
- 6.4
- Editorial score
- #112
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 7.6
- Best at: Craft
It is not a bad film, and it is often diverting. It is simply hard to see what it adds.
Lucius's rage and resentment are established early, but his transition into a leader never feels fully earned.
A familiar arc
Lucius, who appeared as a boy in the first film, is now a man with a wife and a life in North Africa. His world is destroyed by a Roman invasion, he is enslaved, he wins the favour of an owner with his own agenda, and he rises through the arenas towards Rome and a pair of corrupt emperors. Anyone who has seen Gladiator will recognise nearly every step, including a mentor figure, an ageing Lucilla working behind the scenes and a scheme to restore the dream of a republic.
The film's attempts to deepen this with themes of legacy and inheritance fall flat, partly because they are stated repeatedly in dialogue, and partly because the connection between Lucius and Maximus is used more as fan service than drama.

Performances
Paul Mescal, an excellent actor in intimate dramas, is physically committed but struggles to project the brooding authority that made Russell Crowe's Maximus so compelling. Lucius's rage and resentment are established early, but his transition into a leader never feels fully earned.
Denzel Washington is the film's saving grace. As Macrinus, a former slave turned power broker, he plays every scene with sly amusement and calculating menace, and his manipulations of the imperial court provide the film's most engaging thread. Pedro Pascal brings dignity to General Acacius, but the character is underwritten. Joseph Quinn and Fred Hechinger, as the decadent emperors, lean into camp with some success, although the twins feel more like caricatures than threats.
Spectacle
The action is lavish. The opening attack on the Numidian coast is energetic, and the arena sequences include a fight with savage baboons, a battle against a warrior riding a rhinoceros and a mock naval battle in a flooded Colosseum. Scott stages these with polish and bloodthirsty relish.
Yet the sheer excess, including sharks swimming in the Colosseum, strains even the original's loose relationship with plausibility and pushes the film towards the ridiculous. The heavy use of digital effects makes many of these scenes feel weightless compared with the grit of the first film.
Look and sound
Arthur Max's production design and Janty Yates and David Crossman's costumes make Rome gaudy and imposing. Harry Gregson-Williams's score borrows motifs from the original, but cannot match the emotional pull of Hans Zimmer and Lisa Gerrard's music, and those borrowed cues mostly remind viewers of a better film.
What works
- Denzel Washington's scheming Macrinus is a gleefully entertaining turn
- The opening naval assault on Numidia is a vigorous set piece
- Lavish costumes and sets give Rome a decadent, gaudy grandeur
What doesn’t
- Replays the original's structure almost beat for beat
- Paul Mescal's Lucius lacks the gravity the story demands
- Excessive digital creatures, including sharks, feel absurd
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.68.3
- Story
- 5.66.8
- Direction
- 7.08.1
- Performances
- 7.28.0
Civil War edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
Gladiator II is handsomely produced and occasionally thrilling, with a standout Denzel Washington performance. But its slavish repetition of the original's structure, a lead who never convinces as a successor and escalating digital absurdity leave it hollow. As a sequel to one of the defining epics of its era, it disappoints, and it scores a mixed 6.4.





