Skip to content

Head to head

Civil War vs Gladiator II

Civil War takes it by 1.0, 7.4 against 6.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Civil War
Civil War

2024 · Good

  • Harrowing, precisely staged scenes of violence and fear
  • Kirsten Dunst gives a weary, hollowed-out lead performance
  • Its refusal to explain the war's politics feels evasive
Cover of Gladiator II
Gladiator II

2024 · Mixed

  • Denzel Washington's scheming Macrinus is a gleefully entertaining turn
  • The opening naval assault on Numidia is a vigorous set piece
  • Replays the original's structure almost beat for beat

Where the gap is

Craft
8.37.6
Story
6.85.6
Direction
8.17.0
Performances
8.07.2

At a glance

FactCivil WarGladiator II
Released12 April 202422 November 2024
DirectorAlex GarlandRidley Scott
StarringKirsten Dunst, Wagner Moura, Stephen McKinley HendersonPedro Pascal, Paul Mescal, Connie Nielsen
Runtime109 minutes148 minutes
StudioA24Paramount Pictures, Scott Free Productions
GenreAction · Drama · WarAction · Drama · History

The two verdicts

Civil War

Civil War: a harrowing road movie about the people who photograph collapse

Civil War is gripping, well-acted and technically accomplished, with individual scenes that linger long after it ends. Its studied political vagueness and predictable character arcs, however, stop it from being the searching statement it gestures towards. As a harrowing, sometimes frustrating piece of speculative war cinema, it earns a 7.4.

Read the full review →

Gladiator II

Gladiator II: louder, bloodier and far less memorable than the original

Gladiator II is handsomely produced and occasionally thrilling, with a standout Denzel Washington performance. But its slavish repetition of the original's structure, a lead who never convinces as a successor and escalating digital absurdity leave it hollow. As a sequel to one of the defining epics of its era, it disappoints, and it scores a mixed 6.4.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.