Civil War · 2024
Civil War: a harrowing road movie about the people who photograph collapse
Civil War review: Alex Garland's war-torn America is visceral and superbly staged, but its deliberately vague politics leave this A24 drama feeling evasive.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Civil War imagines the unthinkable, a United States fractured into armed factions, and then chooses to look at it through the eyes of people whose job is to observe rather than take sides. Alex Garland, the writer-director of Ex Machina and Annihilation, delivers a tense, frequently terrifying road movie with some of the most effective scenes of his career. It was a notable commercial success for A24.
- 7.4
- Editorial score
- #104
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 8.3
- Best at: Craft
What it pointedly does not deliver is an explanation. How the war started and what the sides believe is left almost entirely blank, a choice that some found bracingly universal and others found a cop-out.
Occasional use of upbeat songs over scenes of carnage is a deliberate jolt, but it can feel more stylish than meaningful.
On the road
The structure is episodic. Lee, Joel, Sammy and Jessie drive a long, looping route through Pennsylvania and West Virginia to avoid front lines, encountering a series of scenes that offer snapshots of a nation's collapse: a petrol station where armed men have strung up looters, a standoff with an unseen sniper, a strangely normal small town pretending nothing is happening, and a mass grave. Each stop is staged with patient, mounting dread.
The most memorable sequence involves a group of soldiers, led by an uncredited Jesse Plemons, interrogating the journalists at gunpoint about what kind of American they are. It is an almost unbearable scene, and it distils the film's fears into a single roadside confrontation.

Journalists as protagonists
Kirsten Dunst plays Lee as a woman exhausted by years of photographing atrocities abroad, now numb as the horror comes home. It is a quiet, internal performance of real weight. Wagner Moura brings adrenaline-junkie energy to Joel, and Stephen McKinley Henderson is the film's warm moral centre as Sammy, a veteran newspaperman.
Cailee Spaeny's Jessie is written as the inexperienced protégé who learns what the job demands. Spaeny is good, but her arc follows a well-worn path, and the parallels between the young photographer and her mentor are drawn a little heavily.
The politics question
Garland's most controversial choice is the alliance of Texas and California as the Western Forces, a pairing that seems designed to prevent viewers mapping the war onto current partisan lines. The president, played by Nick Offerman, is described as having overstepped his office, but beyond that the film stays vague. The intention is clearly to focus on the mechanics of violence and the fragility of civic order, yet the lack of specificity can make the film feel as though it is avoiding the very questions it raises.
Craft
Technically, Civil War is superb. Rob Hardy's cinematography mixes handheld urgency with still, beautiful compositions, and the use of frozen photographs within scenes emphasises the characters' profession. The sound design is outstanding, with gunfire that is sudden, deafening and disorienting. The final assault on Washington is a gripping piece of large-scale action. Occasional use of upbeat songs over scenes of carnage is a deliberate jolt, but it can feel more stylish than meaningful.
What works
- Harrowing, precisely staged scenes of violence and fear
- Kirsten Dunst gives a weary, hollowed-out lead performance
- Outstanding sound design makes gunfire genuinely shocking
- A tense roadside encounter with a militia is unforgettable
What doesn’t
- Its refusal to explain the war's politics feels evasive
- Jessie's arc as the eager newcomer is predictable
- Some needle-drop montages undercut the film's grit
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.37.6
- Story
- 6.85.6
- Direction
- 8.17.0
- Performances
- 8.07.2
Civil War edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
Civil War is gripping, well-acted and technically accomplished, with individual scenes that linger long after it ends. Its studied political vagueness and predictable character arcs, however, stop it from being the searching statement it gestures towards. As a harrowing, sometimes frustrating piece of speculative war cinema, it earns a 7.4.





