The Gilded Age · 2022
The Gilded Age: Julian Fellowes brings Downton's comforts to old New York society
The Gilded Age review: Julian Fellowes's HBO period drama is opulent and well cast, with Carrie Coon superb, though its conflicts are often too gentle.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
The Gilded Age is built for viewers who miss Downton Abbey, and it knows it. Julian Fellowes transplants his fascination with class, manners and social change from an English country house to the brownstones and mansions of Manhattan, where the conflict is not between upstairs and downstairs so much as between inherited position and new fortunes. The result is sumptuous, well-acted comfort television.
- 7.1
- Editorial score
- #95
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2022
- Released
- 2
- Seasons
Its limitations are equally familiar. The stakes are rarely more serious than an invitation withheld or a charity ball boycotted, and the writing tends to resolve problems gently. The series improves as it goes, but it never becomes especially daring.
Fifth Avenue is recreated with elaborate sets and period streetscapes, and the costumes, with their layered silks, bustles and jewellery, are breathtaking.
Story
The central rivalry between Agnes van Rhijn, an arbiter of old-money propriety, and Bertha Russell, the wife of a ruthless railway magnate, is the engine of the show. Bertha's campaign to gain acceptance from the city's social gatekeepers is played out through dinner parties, opera boxes and wedding plans, and the show is at its best when it treats these battles as a kind of warfare.
The first season, however, is slow, with too many scenes that exist merely to introduce characters and too few that push the plot forward. The second season is widely regarded as an improvement, raising the stakes with labour disputes and business rivalries while giving the society war a more satisfying shape. Even then, the show's tendency to wrap up crises neatly softens the drama.

Characters and performances
Carrie Coon is the standout as Bertha, a woman whose ambition is both admirable and ruthless, and she makes every glacial smile feel like a threat. Morgan Spector's George is a compelling portrait of a charming, dangerous capitalist. Christine Baranski clearly delights in Agnes's snobbery, and her withering exchanges with Cynthia Nixon's gentler Ada are a highlight.
Denée Benton gives Peggy Scott, an aspiring writer from a prosperous Black family in Brooklyn, dignity and fire, and her storyline, which draws on the history of Black middle-class New York, is one of the most interesting threads. Louisa Jacobson's Marian, nominally the protagonist, is sympathetic but thinly written, and her romances are the least engaging part of the series. Audra McDonald and Nathan Lane lend weight in supporting roles.
Craft
The production is unarguably impressive. Fifth Avenue is recreated with elaborate sets and period streetscapes, and the costumes, with their layered silks, bustles and jewellery, are breathtaking. The Russell mansion is a spectacular showcase for Bertha's taste for excess, contrasting with the older, darker interiors of the van Rhijn household. The score is lush and romantic, reinforcing the show's escapist appeal.
Who it is for
The Gilded Age is perfect for period drama fans who enjoy intrigue, fashion and witty put-downs. It is best approached as a comfort watch rather than a challenging historical study. Viewers seeking a sharp critique of American capitalism will find it too affectionate towards its wealthy characters.
What works
- Carrie Coon's steely social climber Bertha Russell is a riveting lead
- Christine Baranski delivers withering one-liners with evident relish
- Costumes and sets recreate 1880s Manhattan in dazzling detail
- Peggy Scott's storyline opens a window onto Black New York society
What doesn’t
- The first season's stakes are low and its pacing distinctly sluggish
- Marian Brook is a bland centre compared with the older characters
- Social rivalries resolve too neatly to create real tension
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.99.1
- Story
- 6.68.1
- Characters
- 7.28.5
- Performances
- 8.48.9
Pachinko edges it by 1.2. See them side by side
The verdict
The Gilded Age is handsome, entertaining and graced with fine performances, particularly from Carrie Coon and Christine Baranski. Its gentle conflicts, sluggish start and weak central heroine keep it from greatness. A 7.1 reflects a well-crafted period drama that offers plenty of pleasure but little bite.





