The Irishman · 2019
The Irishman: Scorsese's mob epic becomes a long, sombre reckoning
The Irishman review: Martin Scorsese's three-and-a-half-hour crime saga with De Niro, Pacino and Pesci is a masterful, mournful study of loyalty and regret.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Irishman is Martin Scorsese's return to the organised crime genre he helped define, but it is less a celebration of that world than a mournful reckoning with it. Reuniting with Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci and working with Al Pacino for the first time, Scorsese tells a sprawling story of power, loyalty and violence, then lets its final hour settle into something quiet, lonely and deeply moving.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #53
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 9.2
- Best at: Direction
Released largely through Netflix after a limited cinema run, the film was widely acclaimed. It demands a considerable commitment of time, and it is not free of flaws, but its cumulative power is remarkable.
Stephen Graham is superb as a volatile union rival, and Ray Romano and Harvey Keitel make strong impressions.
Story
Frank Sheeran narrates his story from old age, and the film moves between several timelines, including a road trip with Russell Bufalino and their wives to a wedding. Frank's path begins when he meets Russell while working as a lorry driver delivering meat. He becomes a trusted enforcer and eventually a friend and bodyguard to Jimmy Hoffa, the powerful, stubborn union boss whose relationship with the mob grows increasingly tense.
The film is based on Sheeran's own claims, some of which historians have strongly disputed, and it should be approached as a dramatisation rather than a definitive account. The screenplay deliberately strips away the excitement of Scorsese's earlier gangster films. Killings are quick, flat and matter-of-fact, captioned with the grim fates of various mobsters. For long stretches, the narrative consists of meetings, political manoeuvring and petty disputes, which gives it authenticity but also makes the middle section feel laborious. The final hour, focusing on the emotional cost of Frank's life, gives everything that came before a devastating new weight.

Direction and craft
Scorsese's direction is patient and precise. Rodrigo Prieto's photography subtly shifts in look across different decades, and Thelma Schoonmaker's editing gives even the most mundane scenes a sense of rhythm. The use of period songs is more restrained than in earlier Scorsese crime films.
The most discussed element is the digital de-ageing used to make the actors appear younger in earlier scenes. It is impressive at times, but it is also inconsistent. Faces can look smoothed, and the actors' movements often betray their real ages, particularly in an awkward scene in which a supposedly younger Frank beats a shopkeeper.
Performances
Robert De Niro gives Frank a guarded, inexpressive quality that suits a man who follows orders without examining them. His best work comes late, as Frank confronts the consequences of his life. Al Pacino is enormously entertaining as Hoffa, a man consumed by pride and grudges, and his scenes crackle with comic and dramatic energy.
Joe Pesci, persuaded out of semi-retirement, gives the film's finest performance. His Russell is soft-spoken, patient and deeply menacing, the opposite of the explosive gangsters he played in the past. Stephen Graham is superb as a volatile union rival, and Ray Romano and Harvey Keitel make strong impressions. Anna Paquin, as Frank's daughter Peggy, is powerfully expressive through silence, and while her minimal dialogue is thematically meaningful, many viewers felt the character deserved more.
Who it is for
The Irishman is for viewers who love Scorsese, crime dramas and slow-burning character studies, and for anyone interested in twentieth-century American history. At three and a half hours, it can be watched in more than one sitting, although its final effect is strongest when experienced as a whole.
What works
- Joe Pesci's quiet, controlled Russell Bufalino is a revelation
- Al Pacino's volcanic, funny Jimmy Hoffa gives the film enormous energy
- The final hour is a profound meditation on age, guilt and loneliness
- Scorsese deconstructs the glamour of his own gangster films
What doesn’t
- Digital de-ageing is often distracting, especially in physical scenes
- The running time makes the middle section feel heavy and repetitive
- Anna Paquin's Peggy is crucial but given almost no dialogue
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.49.0
- Story
- 8.48.3
- Direction
- 9.29.2
- Performances
- 9.29.3
Dead level: both score 8.6.See them side by side
The verdict
The Irishman is a masterful, elegiac late-career work with outstanding performances and a devastating final act. Its inconsistent de-ageing effects, sprawling middle and underused female characters keep it below Scorsese's very best films, but it remains a profound and haunting reflection on violence, loyalty and regret.





