Skip to content
Book reviewExcellent

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny · 2025

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny: a vast, patient love story that earns most of its length

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny review. Kiran Desai's Booker-shortlisted return is a generous, funny, overlong epic of love, family and displacement.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Kiran Desai waited nearly two decades to follow The Inheritance of Loss, and The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny reads like a book that refused to be hurried at any stage. It is a romance, a family saga, a comedy of manners about Indians abroad and at home, and an argument about what it costs to leave a place. It is also very long, and the length is both its pleasure and its problem.

8.4
Editorial score
#35
Of 61 books reviewed
2025
Released
688 pages
Pages

The surprise is how light it often feels. Desai writes about exile, class resentment and the quiet violence of families with a comic timing that keeps the pages turning, and the loneliness of the title is treated as a condition worth studying rather than a mood to wallow in. When the novel works, which is most of the time, it feels like a nineteenth-century social novel that has been handed a passport and a long-distance phone card.

The premise

Sonia and Sunny almost never meet. Years before the novel begins, their grandparents tried to arrange a marriage between them, a clumsy piece of meddling that left both young people embarrassed and determined to avoid each other. Sonia has been finishing her studies at a college in Vermont, writing fiction in the snow and falling under the control of Ilan de Toorjen Foss, a much older and more famous artist whose influence curdles into something closer to possession. Sunny works for the Associated Press in New York, lives with an American girlfriend, Ulla, and keeps an ocean between himself and his mother, Babita.

The two finally cross paths on an overnight train in India, and what follows is a romance that keeps being interrupted: by families, by money, by the pull of two continents and by Sonia's growing conviction that Ilan has left a dark spell on her. That is as far as the first act goes, and as far as this review will. The novel is set mostly between 1996 and 2002, a window Desai chooses carefully: the years when a young Indian in America was still expected to choose one life or the other.

  1. 1998

    Desai's first novel, Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard, is published

  2. 2006

    The Inheritance of Loss wins the Booker Prize

  3. July 2025

    The new novel is longlisted for the Booker Prize before publication

  4. 23 September 2025

    Published by Hogarth in the US, and shortlisted the same day

  5. 10 November 2025

    David Szalay's Flesh takes the prize; Desai's novel stays on the shortlist

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny
The Loneliness of Sonia and SunnyThe Center for Fiction, event card with the Hogarth jacket, via YouTube

The writing

Desai's sentences are the main event. She has a painter's eye for rooms and weather, and an even sharper ear for how families talk: the passive-aggressive blessing, the gossip disguised as concern, the complaint about a servant that is really about a daughter. Scenes in Delhi households are crowded and loud, and she gives each voice in the room its own cadence without ever losing control of the paragraph.

The comedy matters. Sunny's office life in New York, with its careful performance of being the right kind of foreigner, is written with the dry wit of someone who has watched that performance closely. Sonia's life with Ilan is funny in a darker way, because the absurdity of his pronouncements about authenticity and art is exactly what makes him frightening. Desai can turn a scene from farce to dread inside a page and make the turn feel earned rather than engineered.

A love story in which the lovers keep being outnumbered by their relatives, their countries and their own doubts.

There is also a thread of the uncanny running beneath the realism. Sonia's fear that Ilan has bewitched her surfaces as visions and omens, never quite confirmed and never quite dismissed. Readers of One Hundred Years of Solitude will recognise the move, though Desai keeps it closer to psychology than to fable. The effect is a realist novel that keeps hearing a dog bark somewhere in the dark.

Watch
The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny — trailer

Story and structure

The structure is the weakest link, and it follows from the book's ambitions. Desai moves between Sonia and Sunny in long alternating stretches, then widens the lens to grandparents, parents, cooks and drivers, each of whom is given a past. Individually, these detours are often the best writing in the book. Together, in the middle third, they slow the main story to a crawl, and the romance that the first act sets up so carefully is left waiting for long periods.

Some of the subplots set in India, particularly those that circle Babita and the wider family's business and feuds, have a melodramatic energy that sits awkwardly beside the quieter material. They raise the stakes, but they also make the novel feel, for a few hundred pages, like two books sharing a binding. Patient readers will forgive the seams; impatient ones will notice little else.

How it reads

Pace
5/10
Unhurried throughout, slack in the middle third
Prose density
8/10
Rich, observant sentences on almost every page
Comedy
8/10
Sharper and more frequent than the title suggests
Romance
6/10
Moving when the couple is together, which is less often than hoped
Accessibility
6/10
Straightforward to follow, demanding to finish
Gallery · 3 imagesAudiobook edition read by Sneha Mathan, Google Play Books, via YouTube · Hamish Hamilton, UK hardback with the Booker Prize 2025 shortlist roundel, via Penguin UK · Edition cover via Open Library

Characters

Sonia and Sunny are drawn with care, and their mutual hesitation is convincing. Sonia is talented, anxious and drawn to people who will define her; Sunny is ironic and evasive, a man who has made escaping his mother the project of his adult life. The trouble is that both are more reactive than the people around them, which is partly the point and partly a limitation: the lovers are often the least lively people in their own scenes.

The supporting cast is extraordinary. Grandparents with long memories and colonial manners, mothers who wield guilt like a family heirloom, servants who see everything and are seen by no one: Desai gives each a history, and even a character who appears for a single scene arrives with the weight of a life behind them. Ilan, in particular, is a superb monster, charming and ridiculous and controlling at once. Few recent novels have caught the specific danger of a mentor who mistakes a younger woman for his material.

The ideas

The book's argument is about loneliness as a structural condition rather than a personal failing. Desai's characters are lonely because of borders, class, race and the way families keep score across generations, and the novel is interested in how those pressures land on two people who would quite like to just be in love. The question of who gets to tell an Indian story, and for whom, runs through Sonia's ambitions as a writer and through Ilan's contempt for anything he calls exotic.

Comparisons with [The Remains of the Day](/item/the-remains-of-the-day) are useful only up to a point: both books understand how duty and class teach people to suppress what they want. Desai's novel is louder, warmer and messier, and far more interested in whether a person can belong to two places without being torn in half. It does not pretend the answer is easy, which is why its moments of tenderness carry weight.

Editions and the shortlist

The novel arrived with a great deal of attention. It was longlisted for the Booker Prize in the summer of 2025, before most readers could buy it, and made the shortlist on the day of its US publication. Penguin's current UK jacket carries the shortlist roundel. The prize went to David Szalay's Flesh, a book about as different in method as two novels can be: spare, short and close to one man, against Desai's sprawl.

Editions in English
EditionPublisherDateFormat
US first editionHogarth23 September 2025Hardback, 688 pages
UK first editionHamish Hamilton25 September 2025Hardback, 688 pages
AudiobookPenguin Random House23 September 2025Unabridged, read by Sneha Mathan

The book rewards a reader who treats it as a season rather than a weekend. It is a novel to carry around, to put down after a long family scene and return to the next day, and it is better read that way than in a single determined push.

For you if

  • Readers who love long family novels and want to live inside one for weeks
  • Anyone interested in fiction about migration, class and the Indian diaspora
  • Fans of The Inheritance of Loss who have waited since 2006

Not for you if

  • Readers who want a tightly plotted romance that keeps its couple on the page
  • Anyone short of patience for long digressions about secondary characters
  • Readers who prefer the lean, focused novels of the same shortlist

For readers who want to sample before committing to nearly seven hundred pages, the publisher's page carries the description and the full edition details.

What works

  • Comic set pieces about families, servants and visas that land as sharply as the sad ones
  • Minor characters, from cooks to great-aunts, each get a history rather than a function
  • Sonia's fear of a dark spell gives the realism a strange, unsettling undertow
  • A love story that treats migration and class as forces, not scenery

What doesn’t

  • At 688 pages the middle stretches sag under repeated arguments and detours
  • The central couple is apart for long sections, which slackens the romance
  • Some secondary plotlines in India feel bolted on rather than woven in

Head to head

Ideas
8.88.4
Story
7.88.2
Writing
8.99.0
Characters
8.68.8

Flesh edges it by 0.3. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny is a generous, intelligent and often very funny novel that would be stronger at two thirds of its length. Desai's prose, her eye for families and her refusal to make any character merely useful put it among the richest literary novels of its year, and its ideas about belonging and authorship stay with a reader long after the plot has blurred. The score is held below the top tier by a slack middle and a central romance that spends too much time offstage. For readers willing to give it the weeks it asks for, it repays the investment with a whole crowded world, and with two lonely people who are worth the wait.

Quick answers

Is The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny worth reading?

Voxizer scores The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny (2025) 8.4 out of 10 — excellent. The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny is a generous, intelligent and often very funny novel that would be stronger at two thirds of its length. Desai's prose, her eye for families and her refusal to make any character merely useful put it among the richest literary novels of its year, and its ideas about belonging and authorship stay with a reader long after the plot has blurred.

Who will enjoy The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny?

Readers who love long family novels and want to live inside one for weeks. Anyone interested in fiction about migration, class and the Indian diaspora. Fans of The Inheritance of Loss who have waited since 2006.

Who should skip The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny?

Readers who want a tightly plotted romance that keeps its couple on the page. Anyone short of patience for long digressions about secondary characters. Readers who prefer the lean, focused novels of the same shortlist.

What is The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny like, in short?

A big, old-fashioned novel of love and family, written with real comic precision. Sonia and Sunny are vivid, but the supporting cast is where the book's richness lives. The ideas about migration, art and belonging are the reason to read it. The middle third is slack, and the couple spends too long apart.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for books: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.