The Name of the Wind · 2007
The Name of the Wind: gorgeous prose and a legend in the making, if too perfect a hero
In Patrick Rothfuss's The Name of the Wind, Kvothe tells his own story, from travelling troupe to the University. Beautifully written, if slow and indulgent.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
The Name of the Wind became one of the most celebrated fantasy debuts of its era, admired for its lyrical prose and its intimate take on the familiar tale of a young hero's rise. Rather than beginning with prophecy or war, it begins with a tired innkeeper who was once the most famous man in the world, and who agrees to tell the truth behind the stories told about him.
- 8.2
- Editorial score
- #44
- Of 61 books reviewed
- 2007
- Released
- 662
- Pages
It is a book of great charm and considerable indulgence. Readers tend either to adore it or to grow impatient with its hero.
Rothfuss writes with a musician's sense of rhythm, and passages about music, silence and love are genuinely beautiful.
The frame
The novel's present-day sections, set in a small inn called the Waystone, are among its most intriguing. Kvothe lives under an assumed name, apparently diminished, with a strange apprentice named Bast who is clearly more than he seems. There are hints of broken powers, dangerous creatures and a world falling into disorder. These interludes lend the story a melancholy undertone and pose a compelling question: how did a legend end up here?
This structure also allows Rothfuss to explore the gap between myth and truth. Kvothe is aware of the stories told about him, and he frequently corrects or complicates them, although his own narration is not necessarily reliable.

Growing up Kvothe
The early chapters with Kvothe's family troupe are warm, and his first lessons in sympathy, a magic system based on connections, energy and concentration, are gripping. After tragedy strikes, the story moves to the city of Tarbean, where Kvothe lives as a starving street child. This section is bleak and important to his character but slow, and it tests readers' patience.
Once Kvothe arrives at the University, the novel finds its stride. His admission interview, rivalry with the wealthy student Ambrose, work in the Artificery, music performances and dealings with eccentric Masters are highly entertaining. Rothfuss makes the practicalities of student life, including tuition fees and part-time jobs, surprisingly engaging.
Hero or legend
The main criticism of the novel concerns Kvothe himself. He is a prodigy at music, magic, languages, acting and nearly everything else, and though he makes mistakes and suffers setbacks, his talent can make him seem too extraordinary for his struggles to feel precarious. Some readers see this as part of the unreliable-narrator conceit; others find it wearing.
Denna, his love interest, is beautiful, mysterious and frequently absent, but she remains more a figure of fascination than a person with a fully realised inner life. Auri, a fragile girl who lives beneath the University, and the eccentric Master Elodin are more memorable secondary characters.
Style
The prose is the book's great strength. Rothfuss writes with a musician's sense of rhythm, and passages about music, silence and love are genuinely beautiful. Yet his willingness to linger means the novel can feel longer than necessary, and major plot threads, including the mystery of the Chandrian, advance slowly. The trilogy's concluding volume has been awaited for many years, a factor worth considering for new readers.
Who it is for
It will appeal to readers who enjoy character-focused fantasy, beautiful writing and magic schools. Those looking for tight plotting, morally complex heroes or a completed story may be frustrated.
What works
- Lyrical, musical prose rare in epic fantasy
- The framing story creates intrigue about how a legend became an innkeeper
- Sympathy magic is logical, inventive and grounded in scholarship
- University life is vivid, from lectures to money worries
What doesn’t
- Kvothe excels at nearly everything, draining some tension
- Denna is more an enigma than a well-developed character
- Pacing is slow, especially the long street-urchin section
Head to head
- Ideas
- 8.18.7
- Story
- 7.78.6
- Writing
- 8.97.0
- Characters
- 7.68.0
The Name of the Wind edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
The Name of the Wind is an elegantly written and deeply atmospheric fantasy with an intriguing frame and one of the genre's most engaging depictions of magical education. An overpowered protagonist, underdeveloped romantic interest and leisurely pacing keep it from greatness, but its prose and storytelling charm make it an excellent, if indulgent, read.




