Skip to content
Comic reviewExcellent

The Nice House on the Lake · 2021

The Nice House on the Lake: an apocalypse told as a weekend away with old friends

The Nice House on the Lake review. Tynion and Martínez Bueno's twelve-issue horror comic finds its dread in comfort, friendship and a host nobody really knew.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

The most frightening room in The Nice House on the Lake is the kitchen. It is clean, well stocked and full of light, and the people standing in it have just been told that everyone else they have ever known is about to die. James Tynion IV and Álvaro Martínez Bueno built a twelve-issue horror comic on that contrast, and the result is a story of the apocalypse in which almost nothing happens on screen and almost everything happens in the faces of people trying to be polite to their host.

8.6
Editorial score
#29
Of 53 comics reviewed
2021
Released
9.4
Best at: Art

It is a comic about friendship and about the specific dread of realising that a friend has been keeping a version of you in a drawer. The monster, as far as the first act lets on, is hospitality. That idea carries the series further than the plot does, and it is why the book remains one of the most distinctive horror comics of the decade so far even when its middle stretch loses its grip.

The premise

Walter has always been the odd one in the group: the friend from school, or from university, or from a job, depending on whom you ask. He invites a set of people who know him from different points in his life to spend some time at a house he has access to beside a lake in the woods. Several of the guests barely know each other. The house is modern, expensive and remote, and the invitation arrives after a hard year for nearly all of them, which is the only reason most of them say yes.

On the first night, the phones start to show what is happening outside. The world beyond the lake is ending, quickly, and the guests cannot leave. Walter is calm in a way that does not fit, and he seems to know far more than a host should. That is the first act, and the series is careful not to make it louder than it needs to be. The horror is not the catastrophe. It is the question of why these people, and why Walter thought they would be grateful.

The Nice House on the Lake
The Nice House on the LakeÁlvaro Martínez Bueno and Jordie Bellaire / DC

The writing

Tynion writes horror as a series of social situations. The best scenes are arguments over dinner, half-confessions on a jetty, and the slow realisation among the guests that they each describe Walter differently. The dialogue overlaps and interrupts, and the people in it sound like adults with history rather than archetypes in a cabin. Some readers will find the chatter heavy; for most, it is where the dread lives, because the reader is always waiting for someone to say the thing nobody wants said.

He is also more restrained here than in his other horror work. [Something is Killing the Children](/item/something-is-killing-the-children) is built on a creature and a hunter; this series is built on an absence, a thing that has happened just out of frame. Tynion trusts the reader to fill that absence, and the opening issues are the better for it. When the series later starts to explain itself, it loses some of that charge, though the explanations are handled more carefully than in most stories that set up a mystery this large.

  1. March 2021

    DC announces the series for its Black Label imprint as a twelve-issue first season

  2. June 2021

    Issue #1 is published

  3. 2022

    The first six issues are collected; the series wins the Eisner Award for Best New Series

  4. December 2022

    The twelfth and final issue closes the story

  5. October 2023

    The Deluxe Edition gathers all twelve issues in one hardcover

  6. 2024

    The Nice House by the Sea begins, with a new house and a new cast

The writing's weakness is structural rather than line by line. With a large cast and only twelve issues, Tynion has to choose whose story to tell in each instalment, and some guests are reduced to a single trait and a symbol for long stretches. The ones he does focus on, especially Ryan, the artist who is closest to being the reader's eyes, carry the book. The rest are vivid in the frame and thin on the page.

The art

Álvaro Martínez Bueno draws the house as if he were selling it. The opening spreads of the lake at dusk, with the building lit up on the hill and the water perfectly still, could be property listings. That is the joke and the threat at once: every surface is beautiful, every room is clean, and the more inviting the place looks the more it reads as a trap. His figures are realistic and expressive without being stiff, and he is very good at the small physical tells of people who are frightened and trying to stay civil.

The more inviting the house looks, the more it reads as a trap.

Jordie Bellaire's colour is the quiet engine of the book. The present is cold, all teal water, dark trees and lamp-lit glass; the memories of each guest's history with Walter are warmer and softer, so the reader can tell where they are in time before reading a word. AndWorld Design's contribution is easy to overlook and should not be. Each guest has a title, The Writer, The Doctor, The Comedian, and a circular symbol, and those designs recur across covers, title pages and the guide to the characters. In a book with this many faces, that system does the job a cast list would otherwise have to.

Gallery · 3 imagesÁlvaro Martínez Bueno and Jordie Bellaire / DC · Álvaro Martínez Bueno / DC · Edition cover via Open Library

Characters

The guests are a cross-section of creative and professional America: an artist, a writer, a reporter, a scientist, a doctor, a comedian, an accountant, a consultant and others. Tynion uses that spread to ask what each kind of person does when the rules of their life stop applying. The scientist wants an explanation, the reporter wants a story, the comedian wants the room to relax. These instincts collide in ways that are often funny and occasionally cruel.

Walter is the series' best creation. He is awkward, earnest and deeply sincere about wanting his friends to be happy, and that sincerity is what makes him unsettling. He never behaves like a villain in the first act; he behaves like a host who has gone to a great deal of trouble and is hurt that nobody is thanking him. Readers who have known someone like Walter will recognise him at once, which is the point.

The ensemble's weakness is the cost of its size. A reader will finish the first volume able to describe four or five guests well and the others mainly by their symbols. Some come into focus later, others never quite do. It is a common problem in ensemble horror, and the series' ambition makes it more visible rather than less.

Pacing and format

The first issue is close to perfect: a slow, warm arrival, a turn, and a final page that changes the genre of the book. The next few issues hold that tension well. The trouble comes in the middle, where the guests argue, form factions and talk through the situation at length, and the series spends more time on its rules than on its fear. It recovers in the final stretch, but readers who prefer momentum will feel the drag.

The format matters here. The story falls into two halves of six issues, and the collected editions follow that split. For anyone starting now, the gap between the halves that monthly readers experienced is gone, and the book reads much better for it.

Collected editions
EditionIssuesPublishedWorth knowing
Vol. 1 (paperback)#1–6March 2022The first half; ends on a strong turn
Vol. 2 (paperback)#7–12March 2023Completes the story
The Deluxe Edition (hardcover)#1–12October 2023Whole series in one book, with design and development material

The follow-up, The Nice House by the Sea, is a separate series with a new location and a new cast, and it is not needed to make sense of this one. The original story is complete in twelve issues.

Where to start

For horror on the comics shelf, the natural comparison is Junji Ito's [Uzumaki](/item/uzumaki), another story about a small group trapped in a place that has quietly turned against them. Ito's horror is in the drawing of the impossible; Tynion and Martínez Bueno's is in the drawing of the comfortable. Readers who liked one will usually find something in the other.

Head to head

Art
9.49.8
Story
8.48.9
Pacing
7.78.6
Characters
8.17.8

Uzumaki edges it by 0.5. See them side by side

The other close neighbour in the catalogue is [Locke & Key](/item/locke-and-key), which also uses a beautiful house as the engine of its dread, though with a younger cast and a more adventurous tone.

For you if

  • Readers who prefer dread and character to gore and jump scares
  • Anyone drawn to ensemble stories about old friendships under pressure
  • Fans of painterly, cinematic art and expressive colour

Not for you if

  • Readers who want a fast plot and a single clear protagonist
  • Anyone who loses patience with long dialogue scenes
  • Readers who want every mystery solved neatly

The deluxe hardcover is the most complete way to read it, but the first paperback is enough to know whether the series is for you.

What works

  • A first issue that turns a holiday into a trap in a handful of pages
  • Martínez Bueno draws the house so lovingly that its comfort becomes the threat
  • Bellaire's colour separates memory from the present without a caption
  • Each guest's symbol and title give a large cast an instant visual shorthand

What doesn’t

  • Some of the guests get far less room than the cast list promises
  • The middle issues talk through their tension rather than dramatising it
  • Read monthly, the gap between the two halves blunted the momentum
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

The Nice House on the Lake is a horror comic that understands what is frightening about being looked after by someone who has decided what is good for you. Martínez Bueno's art and Bellaire's colour make the house the most memorable setting in recent mainstream comics, and Walter is a villain, if that is the word, unlike any other. The score is held back by a cast that is larger than the series can fully serve and a middle stretch that explains when it should unsettle. Read in collected form, with the break between halves removed, those problems shrink, and what remains is a confident, unusual piece of horror that earns its reputation.

Quick answers

Is The Nice House on the Lake worth reading?

Voxizer scores The Nice House on the Lake (2021) 8.6 out of 10 — excellent. The Nice House on the Lake is a horror comic that understands what is frightening about being looked after by someone who has decided what is good for you. Martínez Bueno's art and Bellaire's colour make the house the most memorable setting in recent mainstream comics, and Walter is a villain, if that is the word, unlike any other.

Who will enjoy The Nice House on the Lake?

Readers who prefer dread and character to gore and jump scares. Anyone drawn to ensemble stories about old friendships under pressure. Fans of painterly, cinematic art and expressive colour.

Who should skip The Nice House on the Lake?

Readers who want a fast plot and a single clear protagonist. Anyone who loses patience with long dialogue scenes. Readers who want every mystery solved neatly.

What is The Nice House on the Lake like, in short?

A slow, uneasy horror story about friendship, with the end of the world kept mostly off the page. Álvaro Martínez Bueno's art makes luxury feel like a cage, and it is the series' strongest asset. Jordie Bellaire's colours and AndWorld Design's symbols make a crowded cast easy to follow. The middle issues sag, and not every guest is given a full story.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed The Nice House on the Lake yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.