The Tortured Poets Department · 2024
The Tortured Poets Department: Taylor Swift's heartbreak saga needed an editor
The Tortured Poets Department is Taylor Swift's sprawling 2024 double album, with sharp, raw songs about heartbreak and fame lost among too much similar filler.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
Taylor Swift entered 2024 at the height of her commercial power, and The Tortured Poets Department reflects that position in both good and bad ways. It is a record made without constraint: long, confessional, heavy with detail and released in two instalments that together run to around two hours. Its streaming debut was record-breaking, and its audience embraced it immediately. Critical reception was more divided, and for understandable reasons.
- 6.8
- Editorial score
- #44
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 65 minutes
- Length
There is a very good album of about a dozen songs somewhere inside The Tortured Poets Department. The problem is that finding it requires patience, and the surrounding material often weakens rather than supports it.
The problem is that finding it requires patience, and the surrounding material often weakens rather than supports it.
The best songs
When the writing is sharp, it is among Swift's most emotionally raw work. So Long, London, with its looping choral opening and gradual build, is a vivid portrait of a relationship slowly draining away. loml is a quiet, devastating piano ballad that turns a familiar phrase inside out. Who's Afraid of Little Old Me? channels anger at public scrutiny into a dramatic, almost gothic performance, and Florida!!! with Florence + the Machine is a stormy duet about escape.
The Anthology edition contains some of the strongest material. The Black Dog captures the pain of watching an ex move on with piercing specificity, and The Bolter is a sharp character study.

Where it falters
The production is the album's biggest weakness. Jack Antonoff's contributions often favour a muted, mid-tempo synth-pop palette, with soft drum programming and hazy keyboards, and track after track settles into the same subdued groove. Aaron Dessner's songs, dominant on the Anthology, are more organic but also blend together over time. Across two hours, the lack of variation makes it hard for individual songs to stand out.
The lyrics, usually Swift's greatest strength, are uneven. Moments of piercing insight sit beside awkward rhymes, clumsy references and lines that seem written for fans eager to decode personal details rather than for the song itself. The title track is a clear example, sharp in places yet undermined by distracting specifics.
Performance
Swift's vocals remain assured and expressive, even when the production does little to lift them. She is particularly effective on the more intimate ballads, where her phrasing carries the emotion. Post Malone's contribution to Fortnight is understated to the point of anonymity, but Florence Welch brings a much-needed jolt of theatrical energy.
Who it is for
Dedicated fans will find plenty to explore, from diaristic confessions to character sketches. Casual listeners would be better served by a self-made playlist of the strongest songs, or by starting with folklore and evermore, where Swift's collaborations with Dessner are more consistently realised.
What works
- So Long, London and loml rank with Swift's most affecting ballads
- Unguarded writing about grief, obsession and public scrutiny
- Florida!!! with Florence + the Machine brings welcome drama
- The Black Dog is a vivid, precisely observed song of heartbreak
What doesn’t
- Thirty-one tracks and two hours of music bury the strongest songs
- Muted synth-pop production makes much of the album sound the same
- Clumsy lines and in-jokes undercut several otherwise strong songs
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 6.28.6
- Production
- 6.49.0
- Performance
- 7.58.7
- Songwriting
- 7.08.5
HIT ME HARD AND SOFT edges it by 1.6. See them side by side
The verdict
The Tortured Poets Department scores 6.8, placing it in mixed territory. Its best songs are strong, some among the most emotionally affecting of Swift's career, and her voice and commitment are never in doubt. But the album's excessive length, repetitive production and uneven lyrics dilute its impact. With rigorous editing, it could have been one of her finest records; as released, it is a frustrating, overstuffed collection.





