Skip to content

Head to head

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT vs The Tortured Poets Department

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT takes it by 1.6, 8.4 against 6.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of HIT ME HARD AND SOFT
HIT ME HARD AND SOFT

2024 · Excellent

  • Songs flow into one another like movements in a larger suite
  • Finneas's production shifts mood and genre without losing coherence
  • Several tracks change direction midway, sometimes at the melody's expense
Cover of The Tortured Poets Department
  • So Long, London and loml rank with Swift's most affecting ballads
  • Unguarded writing about grief, obsession and public scrutiny
  • Thirty-one tracks and two hours of music bury the strongest songs

Where the gap is

Cohesion
8.66.2
Production
9.06.4
Performance
8.77.5
Songwriting
8.57.0

At a glance

FactHIT ME HARD AND SOFTThe Tortured Poets Department
Released17 May 202419 April 2024
ArtistBillie EilishTaylor Swift
LabelInterscope Records, DarkroomRepublic Records
Tracks1016 (31 in The Anthology edition)
Length43:0065 minutes
GenreAlternative rock · PopAlternative rock · Pop

The two verdicts

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT: Billie Eilish and Finneas make pop that flows like a film

HIT ME HARD AND SOFT scores 8.4 as an excellent, cohesive album with a clear artistic vision. The production and sequencing are outstanding, and its best songs combine emotional honesty with sharp craft. A tendency to abandon songs midstream and a couple of tracks that feel underdeveloped hold it back from the highest tier, but it is the most complete statement of Eilish's career so far, and both critics and listeners embraced it.

Read the full review →

The Tortured Poets Department

The Tortured Poets Department: Taylor Swift's heartbreak saga needed an editor

The Tortured Poets Department scores 6.8, placing it in mixed territory. Its best songs are strong, some among the most emotionally affecting of Swift's career, and her voice and commitment are never in doubt. But the album's excessive length, repetitive production and uneven lyrics dilute its impact. With rigorous editing, it could have been one of her finest records; as released, it is a frustrating, overstuffed collection.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.