The Walking Dead · 2010
The Walking Dead: a zombie phenomenon that shambled on long after its best years
The Walking Dead review: AMC's take on Robert Kirkman's comic began as tense survival horror but grew repetitive over 11 seasons of diminishing returns.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
The Walking Dead began as a remarkable piece of genre television. Its 2010 pilot, directed by Frank Darabont, is a haunting, cinematic study of loneliness in an emptied world, and the early seasons turned a familiar zombie premise into a gripping exploration of what people become when society collapses. It became one of the most-watched dramas on cable, a cultural fixture and the foundation of a franchise.
- 7.0
- Editorial score
- #98
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2010
- Released
- 11
- Seasons
Its longevity, however, was also its undoing. Over eleven seasons, the show repeated its core formula so often that the tension faded, and even its most dedicated fans drifted away during its middle and later years.
Melissa McBride's Carol evolves from a timid, abused wife into a pragmatic, formidable survivor, one of the best character arcs in the series.
Story
The first seasons are lean and frightening. Rick's search for his family leads him to a group of survivors whose conflicts, over leadership, morality and survival, feel urgent. The farm and prison storylines explore how far people will go to protect those they love, and the arrival of the Governor offers a compelling human threat.
After that, the series settles into a pattern: the survivors find a new refuge, encounter a new group, clash with a charismatic villain and suffer losses. Some variations are effective, but the repetition dulls impact. The arrival of Negan, whose introduction became notorious for its brutality and a months-long cliffhanger, signalled a turn towards shock value that alienated many viewers. Later seasons, which saw significant cast turnover and time jumps, contain moments of renewal but struggle with pacing and a sense of purpose.

Characters and performances
Andrew Lincoln gives Rick a raw, anguished intensity, portraying a decent man hardened by circumstance. Norman Reedus's Daryl, a character created for the show, became its most popular figure thanks to his laconic toughness and loyalty. Melissa McBride's Carol evolves from a timid, abused wife into a pragmatic, formidable survivor, one of the best character arcs in the series.
Danai Gurira's sword-wielding Michonne, Lauren Cohan's resilient Maggie and Steven Yeun's warm, resourceful Glenn became cornerstones of the ensemble. Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Negan is charismatic and chilling, though the writing leans heavily on his swagger. The sheer size of the cast means that many characters are underdeveloped, introduced and discarded without real depth.
Craft
The show's craft was consistently strong. Greg Nicotero's makeup effects, producing an astonishing variety of decaying bodies, set new standards for television horror. The Georgia locations, from abandoned highways to overgrown towns, created a convincing post-apocalyptic landscape. Bear McCreary's ominous theme became instantly recognisable. Direction was generally solid, although the show's reliance on extended conversations and slow build-ups became a weakness as pacing faltered.
Who it is for
The Walking Dead is best approached by horror fans who enjoy long-form survival stories, with the first four or five seasons offering the most rewarding experience. Viewers with limited patience may prefer to stop there. Committed fans may find satisfaction in seeing the story to its end and exploring its spin-offs.
What works
- The early seasons deliver bleak, genuinely gripping survival horror
- Greg Nicotero's makeup effects make the walkers grotesquely convincing
- Melissa McBride's Carol undergoes one of TV's great transformations
- Norman Reedus turns the invented Daryl Dixon into a fan-favourite icon
What doesn’t
- Long stretches repeat the same cycle of new community and new villain
- Shock deaths and cliffhangers increasingly feel manipulative
- Pacing in later seasons is sluggish, with heavy filler
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.97.7
- Story
- 6.46.6
- Characters
- 7.47.3
- Performances
- 7.67.6
Dead level: both score 7.0.See them side by side
The verdict
The Walking Dead's early seasons are gripping and influential, with strong performances and outstanding effects. Its later years, however, were marked by repetition, manipulative plotting and sluggish pacing that eroded its impact. A 7.0 reflects a good series with a brilliant start, weighed down by an overlong run.




