The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt · 2015
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt proved side quests could be the heart of an RPG
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt sends Geralt across war-torn lands in search of Ciri. Superb quests and a mature world outweigh clunky combat in a modern classic.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is widely considered one of the greatest role-playing games ever made, and its reputation rests primarily on its storytelling. CD Projekt Red created a vast, detailed world full of morally complex quests and memorable characters, raising expectations for what open-world narratives could achieve. Its combat and systems are less refined, but the quality of its writing and world-building makes those issues easy to overlook.
- 9.4
- Editorial score
- #9
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 9.7
- Best at: Story
Its brilliance lies in how even small tasks can become unforgettable stories.
Players who value strong narratives, mature themes and open-world exploration should consider it essential.
How it plays
Geralt fights using two swords, one steel for humans and one silver for monsters, along with magical signs such as Igni for fire and Quen for shields. Alchemy allows players to craft potions, oils and bombs that exploit enemy weaknesses. Preparation can make difficult fights manageable.
Combat, however, is often clunky. Movement and attacks lack precision, and encounters can feel repetitive, especially on lower difficulties. Later updates improved responsiveness, but it remains the game's weakest element.
Exploration is extensive. Players can ride Roach across regions, uncover points of interest and take monster contracts. Contracts are particularly strong, involving investigation, preparation and dramatic battles. Some activities, such as sailing to treasure markers in Skellige, feel repetitive.
Gwent, a card game playable against characters throughout the world, proved so popular that it later became a standalone game.
Inventory management can be tedious, with large amounts of loot and crafting materials cluttering menus.

World and story
The main story, Geralt's search for Ciri, is emotionally engaging, supported by strong characters such as Yennefer and Triss. Choices have consequences that shape relationships and outcomes, though some effects appear much later.
The side quests are the true highlight. The Bloody Baron questline, early in the game, is a celebrated example of mature storytelling, blending tragedy, family trauma and difficult decisions. Many smaller quests offer surprising twists, humour or heartbreak, rarely resolving neatly.
The world is richly realised. Velen is poor and devastated by war, Novigrad is a crowded city of politics and persecution, and Skellige is a rugged, Norse-inspired archipelago. The expansions add superb content: Hearts of Stone features a dark, fairy-tale inspired story, while Blood and Wine introduces the vibrant region of Toussaint.
Presentation
The art direction is beautiful, with atmospheric weather, detailed environments and striking lighting. The later next-generation update improved visuals and performance on modern platforms.
The soundtrack combines folk instruments and haunting vocals, with combat and exploration themes that are both atmospheric and memorable. Voice acting is strong, particularly Doug Cockle's Geralt.
Who it is for
Players who value strong narratives, mature themes and open-world exploration should consider it essential. Those looking for polished combat may be frustrated, but the story rewards patience.
What works
- Side quests tell morally complex stories that rival most games' main plots
- Geralt is a superbly realised, dryly funny protagonist
- A dense, lived-in world shaped by war, folklore and politics
- Blood and Wine is one of the finest RPG expansions ever released
What doesn’t
- Combat feels stiff and imprecise compared with its storytelling
- Inventory clutter and loot management are tiresome
- Skellige's many sea markers pad out exploration
Head to head
- Story
- 9.76.4
- Gameplay
- 8.38.5
- Longevity
- 9.67.9
- Presentation
- 9.28.1
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt edges it by 1.7. See them side by side
The verdict
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt delivers exceptional storytelling, memorable characters and a richly detailed world, enhanced by two outstanding expansions. Clunky combat, inventory clutter and repetitive exploration elements are real flaws, yet the depth of its quests secures its status as a modern classic.





