The Witcher · 2019
The Witcher: Henry Cavill's monster hunter deserved a sharper, steadier series
The Witcher review: Netflix's take on Andrzej Sapkowski's books has a fine Geralt in Henry Cavill but struggles with muddled plots and uneven craft.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
Few fantasy properties arrived on television with as much goodwill as The Witcher. Andrzej Sapkowski's books had a devoted readership, the CD Projekt Red games were hugely popular, and Henry Cavill, a lifelong fan, was cast as the white-haired monster hunter. The first season became a hit and briefly positioned the show as a serious fantasy contender.
- 6.5
- Editorial score
- #106
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 3
- Seasons
Yet the series never quite lived up to that promise. Its storytelling was often confused, its production uneven, and later seasons were overshadowed by departures from the source material and, ultimately, the departure of its star.
Some fight choreography, notably Geralt's sword battles, is superb, and certain creature designs are effective.
Story
The first season adapts Sapkowski's short stories, interweaving three timelines: Geralt's monster contracts, Yennefer's rise from abused outcast to powerful sorceress and Ciri's flight from a conquered kingdom. The decision not to signal clearly that these strands take place in different eras confused many viewers, undermining the emotional arcs. Standalone monster hunts, however, offer the show's best material, capturing the books' mix of dark fairy tale and moral complexity.
The second season adopts a more conventional structure, focusing on Geralt and Ciri's relationship at the witchers' fortress, and it is often more satisfying emotionally. But it also makes significant changes to the source material, frustrating some fans. The third season, split into two parts, introduces political intrigue and a race to claim Ciri, yet its plotting feels scattered. Throughout, the show's lore and politics are presented in ways that can be difficult to follow.

Characters and performances
Henry Cavill's performance is widely regarded as the show's greatest asset. He plays Geralt as taciturn but warm, with a dry wit and physical presence that feel faithful to the books. Freya Allan grows into the role of Ciri, conveying trauma and determination. Anya Chalotra's Yennefer is ambitious, prickly and complex, and her chemistry with Cavill is a highlight.
Joey Batey's Jaskier, a flamboyant bard, provides humour and heart; his song Toss a Coin to Your Witcher became a popular meme. Supporting performances vary in quality, and many characters, particularly among the kings, mages and elves, are thinly drawn.
Craft
The Witcher's craft is inconsistent. Some fight choreography, notably Geralt's sword battles, is superb, and certain creature designs are effective. However, the visual effects and costumes often look cheap, especially in the first season, where armour and battle scenes lack scale. Locations in Hungary, Poland and elsewhere offer attractive backdrops, and Sonya Belousova and Giona Ostinelli's score draws on folk influences. The production improves in the second season but remains uneven.
Who it is for
The Witcher will appeal to fans of fantasy and of the books or games, particularly those keen to see Cavill's portrayal. Newcomers may find the first season's structure challenging, and those invested in the source material may be frustrated by changes. The second season offers the most accessible entry point for those willing to watch selectively.
What works
- Henry Cavill's gruff, dryly funny Geralt honours the books' hero
- Monster-hunting episodes capture the source's grim fairy-tale spirit
- Joey Batey's Jaskier adds charm, songs and welcome levity
- Anya Chalotra gives Yennefer an intriguing mix of pain and ambition
What doesn’t
- The first season's jumbled timelines confuse more than they intrigue
- Later seasons stray from the books and lose narrative focus
- Inconsistent effects and costumes undercut its epic ambitions
Head to head
- Craft
- 6.68.7
- Story
- 6.06.8
- Characters
- 6.87.6
- Performances
- 7.28.6
House of the Dragon edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
The Witcher has a strong lead performance, engaging monster-hunting episodes and moments of genuine fantasy spectacle. Its confusing narratives, uneven production and loss of focus across seasons prevent it from becoming a genre great. A 6.5 reflects a mixed series that never fully capitalised on its considerable potential.





