Undertale · 2015
Undertale is a small RPG that remembers every choice, and makes them matter
Undertale lets players befriend or fight the monsters of the Underground, blending bullet-hell battles, sharp humour and a story that reacts to every decision.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Undertale is a small game with enormous personality. Created largely by one person, it uses the familiar structure of a role-playing game to explore empathy, choice and consequence. Its combat system invites players to understand enemies rather than defeat them, and its writing blends humour and sincerity in ways that have made it one of the most influential indie games of its decade.
- 9.0
- Editorial score
- #44
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Story
Its presentation is modest, but its ideas are anything but.
Multiple endings offer different perspectives, and experiencing them reveals much of the game's emotional and thematic depth.
How it plays
Encounters begin like a traditional turn-based RPG, with options to Fight, Act, use items or show Mercy. When enemies attack, the player controls a small heart in a box, dodging bullet-hell patterns that reflect each monster's personality.
The Act command is the key innovation. Players can compliment, joke, pet, flirt or perform other actions to change an enemy's mood. Once a monster no longer wants to fight, players can spare them. This transforms battles into puzzles about understanding characters, and many encounters are funny, strange or surprisingly touching.
Boss fights are especially memorable, blending challenging patterns with narrative moments. Each major battle has unique mechanics that reflect the character's story.
The game tracks player choices carefully. Whether players kill or spare monsters shapes dialogue, relationships and outcomes. Undertale also remembers certain actions across playthroughs, creating unsettling moments that reward curiosity.
Puzzles in the Underground are generally simple, and some backtracking can slow pacing.

World and story
The Underground is filled with eccentric characters. Toriel is a caring guardian figure, Papyrus is an enthusiastic skeleton eager to capture a human, and his brother Sans is laid-back and mysterious. Undyne, Alphys and others bring humour and heart.
The writing constantly subverts RPG conventions. Jokes about game design, unexpected dialogue and self-aware moments keep players on their toes. Beneath the humour lies a story about kindness, determination and the weight of choices.
Multiple endings offer different perspectives, and experiencing them reveals much of the game's emotional and thematic depth.
Presentation
The visuals are simple, using basic pixel art. Some players may find them underwhelming, but they are expressive and readable, allowing characters to shine through dialogue and animation.
The soundtrack, composed by Toby Fox, is outstanding. It uses recurring motifs cleverly and features tracks that have become iconic in gaming culture, enhancing emotional moments and boss battles.
Who it is for
Players who enjoy strong writing, humour and choice-driven narratives should play it, ideally without spoilers. Fans of classic RPGs will appreciate its subversions. Those seeking polished visuals or complex systems may find it too simple.
What works
- Every enemy can be spared, turning battles into character-driven puzzles
- Sharp, warm humour and a memorable cast such as Sans, Papyrus and Toriel
- The game reacts to player choices in clever, sometimes unsettling ways
- Toby Fox's soundtrack is among the most beloved in indie games
What doesn’t
- Simple visuals may put off players expecting a polished look
- Some puzzles and backtracking feel basic or slow
- Its full impact depends on replaying, which not every player will do
Head to head
- Story
- 9.49.8
- Gameplay
- 8.68.9
- Longevity
- 8.79.0
- Presentation
- 8.29.2
Disco Elysium edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Undertale combines inventive combat, memorable characters and a story that reacts meaningfully to player choices. Its bare-bones visuals and simple puzzles are obvious limitations, and much of its power only emerges on repeat play. Few games have used their own mechanics to say so much about kindness and consequence, which is why it scores this highly.



