Wolf Hall · 2009
Wolf Hall: the Tudor novel that puts you inside the head of the man in the room
Wolf Hall review. Hilary Mantel's Booker-winning novel turns Thomas Cromwell into a living mind, at the cost of a dense, demanding first hundred pages.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Wolf Hall takes the most familiar story in English history, a king, a divorce and a queen who loses her head, and makes it feel as if nobody in the room knows how it ends. That is the whole trick, and it is a large one. Hilary Mantel writes in the present tense, from so close behind Thomas Cromwell's eyes that the reader hears his thoughts before his words, and the effect is a historical novel that reads like a political thriller narrated by the one person clever enough to see all the moves.
- 9.3
- Editorial score
- #7
- Of 61 books reviewed
- 2009
- Released
- 9.6
- Best at: Writing
It is not an easy book to start. The first hundred pages ask for patience with an unusual pronoun habit, a crowd of men who share three first names, and a narrative that skips years without warning. Readers who give it that patience get one of the defining English novels of its century: funny, cold, tender in places, and more interested in how power works than in who wore what to the coronation.
The premise
The novel opens in 1500 in Putney, with a boy on the cobbles being kicked by his father. Walter Cromwell is a brewer, a blacksmith and a drunk, and the first line of the book is an order to get up. The boy does, and leaves. Mantel skips most of the next quarter-century, the soldiering abroad, the cloth trade in Antwerp, the self-taught law, and picks him up again in 1527 as a married man, a father and the indispensable fixer of Cardinal Wolsey, the most powerful churchman in England.
The engine of the plot is Henry VIII's need for a son and his determination to set aside his marriage to Catherine of Aragon in favour of Anne Boleyn. Wolsey has been charged with arranging it and cannot. When the cardinal's star begins to fall, everyone expects his servant to fall with him. Wolf Hall is the story of why he does not: how a commoner with no title and a reputation for menace becomes useful to a king who has run out of people who will tell him the truth.

The writing
Mantel's prose is the reason to read the book, and it is not the prose of most historical fiction. There is almost no costume-drama scene-setting and very little period vocabulary. Characters speak in a modern register, clipped and sardonic, and Cromwell's inner voice is that of a man perpetually amused by the slowness of those around him. A conversation with the Duke of Norfolk can be as funny as anything in contemporary comic fiction, and a page later the book will stop for a paragraph on grief that is quietly devastating.
The famous difficulty is the pronoun. Cromwell is "he" throughout, even when another man has just been named, and in the early chapters it is easy to lose track of who is speaking or acting. Mantel softens this as the book goes on with an occasional "he, Cromwell", and by the middle the habit has become an asset: the reader stops noticing that every scene is filtered through one consciousness, which is exactly the point. The objection is fair, though, and some readers stop at it.
The question is never what happened. Everyone knows what happened. The question is what it felt like to stand in the room before it did.
The present tense matters as much as the pronoun. A story told in the past tense has an ending waiting behind it; this one has only the next meeting. Henry's moods, Anne's ambitions and the shifting loyalties of the nobility are all experienced as weather, unpredictable and dangerous, and the novel's suspense comes not from events but from watching Cromwell read them a fraction faster than anyone else.
Characters
Mantel's Cromwell is a deliberate act of revision. For centuries he was the villain of the story, most memorably in Robert Bolt's A Man for All Seasons, where he is a sly enforcer set against the saintly Thomas More. Wolf Hall turns the telescope round. Its Cromwell is a reformer, a loving father, a host who feeds the poor at his gate and a man who can quote a merchant's ledger and a psalm in the same breath. He is also frightening, and the novel never pretends otherwise: the threat in him is part of his charm.
The reversal applies to More as well. Seen through Cromwell's eyes, he is pious, witty and cruel, a man who has heretics questioned in his own house. Readers who admire More may find this one-sided, and it is; the book is honest about being a single point of view. What keeps it from becoming a polemic is that every figure in Cromwell's orbit, from Anne Boleyn's sharp, cornered intelligence to the young Rafe Sadler's devotion, is drawn with enough detail to push back against the narrator's verdict.
Story and structure
The book is long, and its shape is not a conventional plot curve. It moves in blocks of a few years at a time, with chapters that slow to a single afternoon and then jump a season. Much of the drama is legal and diplomatic: a petition drafted, an act of Parliament steered, an envoy flattered. Mantel makes these scenes gripping more often than she has any right to, largely because Cromwell enjoys them so much, but readers who come for battles or bedchambers will find the proportions unexpected.
There are domestic stretches too, at Cromwell's house in Austin Friars, and they carry the book's emotional weight. His household of wards, clerks, nephews and in-laws is where the novel shows what he is building and what he stands to lose. These chapters give the politics a cost and a reason. They are also where Mantel's eye for small things, a child's drawing, a spoon, a sleeve, is sharpest.
2009
Wolf Hall is published by Fourth Estate on 30 April
2009
Wins the Booker Prize in October
2010
Wins the National Book Critics Circle Award for fiction
2012
Bring Up the Bodies follows, and also wins the Booker Prize
2015
BBC Two adapts the first two novels as a six-part series
2020
The Mirror and the Light completes the trilogy
The ideas
Underneath the court intrigue, Wolf Hall is a book about how the modern state was assembled by people who did not know they were assembling it. Cromwell's skill is administration: knowing who owes whom, which monastery holds which land, what a document will say before anyone has drafted it. Mantel presents this as a kind of genius, and as a moral hazard. The same talent that feeds the hungry also builds the machinery that can crush a man for his conscience.
The title points the same way. Wolf Hall is the Seymour family's house in Wiltshire, a place the novel mostly hears about, and the name carries the old proverb that man is a wolf to man. Religion in the book is politics by other means, and the English Reformation appears less as a conflict of faith than as a transfer of property and loyalty. That reading will not satisfy everyone, but it is argued with great intelligence.
For readers who like to set a novel against another, the closest companion in our catalogue is a very different book about service, power and self-command, also a Booker winner, also narrated by a man whose loyalty is his whole identity.
Head to head
- Ideas
- 9.29.1
- Story
- 8.88.1
- Writing
- 9.69.6
- Characters
- 9.69.4
Wolf Hall edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
Where Kazuo Ishiguro's butler hides from himself, Mantel's minister sees everything, including his own motives. Read together, The Remains of the Day and Wolf Hall make a fine pair of studies in English deference, one about the servant who never acts and one about the servant who acts for everyone.
For you if
- Readers who enjoy political drama, legal cunning and characters cleverer than everyone around them
- Anyone who knows the Tudors from school or television and wants to see them from a new angle
- Lovers of literary prose who do not mind working for it in the early chapters
Not for you if
- Readers who want a fast plot or plenty of action; most battles here are fought in meetings
- Anyone who finds an unconventional narrative voice an obstacle rather than a pleasure
- Admirers of Thomas More who would rather not see him through a hostile witness
If the opening defeats you, the fix is usually to push on to the Wolsey chapters, where the voice settles and the plot gathers pace. Those who finish tend to go straight on to the second book.
What works
- Present-tense narration makes a story with a known outcome feel undecided
- Cromwell is drawn from the inside, as a mind that is always counting the room
- Dialogue that is dry, quick and often very funny, even in council chambers
- Thomas More and Anne Boleyn are seen through hostile eyes and still feel whole
What doesn’t
- The pronoun "he" for Cromwell causes real confusion in the early chapters
- A cast of several Thomases and Marys needs the list at the front of the book
- Long stretches of legal and diplomatic manoeuvre will test readers after plot
The verdict
Wolf Hall earns its place near the top of the catalogue because it does something historical fiction rarely manages: it removes hindsight. By pinning the reader inside Cromwell's present-tense consciousness, Mantel turns events every schoolchild knows into a series of open questions, and makes a man long cast as a villain into one of the most complex characters in modern English fiction. The prose is dry, witty and exact; the moral argument is serious. The score stops short of the very highest tier because the opening asks more of the reader than it needs to, and because the book's proportions, heavy on procedure and light on incident, will not suit everyone. Those reservations are about the entry fee. What the book delivers once inside is as good as the form gets.





