You · 2018
You: a slick, darkly funny stalker thriller that kept repeating its own trick
You review: Penn Badgley's charming, murderous narrator makes this Netflix thriller addictive, but its formula and implausible plots grow tired across seasons.
Mixed
Editorial score out of 10
You has a clever hook: a romantic thriller narrated by the stalker. Joe Goldberg's inner monologue, full of literary references, self-pity and chilling justifications, invites viewers into his mind, where obsession masquerades as love. Penn Badgley, famous for playing the romantic lead in Gossip Girl, uses that charm to unsettling effect, and the first season's mix of suspense and satire made it a streaming sensation after it moved from Lifetime to Netflix.
- 6.6
- Editorial score
- #104
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
The problem is that the trick works best the first time. Over subsequent seasons, the formula became increasingly repetitive, and the plotting grew so implausible that the tension and satire faded.
Jenna Ortega brings charm to Ellie, a teenage neighbour in the second season, and Charlotte Ritchie adds wit in London.
Story
The first season follows Joe's fixation on Guinevere Beck, an aspiring writer, as he manipulates his way into her life. The show's commentary on how easily social media exposes personal details is sharp, and the escalating danger makes it gripping. The second season moves to Los Angeles, where Joe meets Love Quinn, a character who complicates the dynamic in surprising ways, and it offers a fresh, satirical take on wellness culture.
Later seasons relocate to affluent suburbia and London, where the show experiments with other genres, including a whodunit among the wealthy elite. These variations bring some novelty, but the core pattern of obsession, murder and narrow escape remains. Joe's ability to avoid suspicion strains credulity, and the series increasingly relies on contrivance to keep him in play.

Characters and performances
Penn Badgley is excellent as Joe, whose calm narration and flashes of vulnerability make him both repellent and fascinating. The show's success depends on his ability to make viewers uncomfortable with their own sympathy, and he often achieves it. Elizabeth Lail gives Beck an engaging complexity, while Shay Mitchell's Peach is a sharp, menacing presence in the first season.
Victoria Pedretti's Love is a standout, adding unpredictable energy and a dark dynamic that revitalises the show. Jenna Ortega brings charm to Ellie, a teenage neighbour in the second season, and Charlotte Ritchie adds wit in London. Supporting characters, however, often exist mainly as potential victims or obstacles, limiting their depth.
Craft
You is slick and binge-friendly, with glossy visuals, sharp editing and a steady stream of cliffhangers. Each season's setting is used to satirise a particular social world, from Brooklyn book lovers to Los Angeles influencers and suburban parents. The voiceover narration is the show's key tool, providing dark humour and insight, but it can also become repetitive and over-explanatory. The violence can be brutal, but the tone stays closer to dark comedy than horror.
Who it is for
You will appeal to fans of psychological thrillers and dark satire, especially viewers who enjoy unreliable narrators. The first two seasons offer the most compelling experience. Those uncomfortable with a charismatic villain at the centre or tired of repetitive formulas may lose interest.
What works
- Penn Badgley's creepy, self-deceiving narration is darkly compelling
- Satire of social media oversharing and influencer culture is pointed
- Victoria Pedretti's Love Quinn gives the second season a jolt of energy
- Binge-friendly cliffhangers keep episodes moving at a brisk pace
What doesn’t
- Each season recycles the same obsession, murder and cover-up cycle
- Joe's endless evasion of consequences becomes deeply implausible
- Some viewers read the show as romanticising the stalker it critiques
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.07.0
- Story
- 6.06.2
- Characters
- 6.86.4
- Performances
- 7.86.9
You edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
You is an addictive, darkly funny thriller with a compelling central performance and pointed satire. Its repetitive structure, implausible plotting and questionable glamorisation of its antihero diminish its impact over time. A 6.6 reflects a mixed series that thrived on a clever premise but struggled to evolve.





