Skip to content

Head to head

1984 vs The Master and Margarita

1984 takes it by 0.1, 9.5 against 9.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of 1984
1984

1949 · Masterpiece

  • Telescreens, Newspeak and doublethink remain startlingly precise tools of thought
  • Plain, controlled prose makes the horror feel procedural rather than fantastical
  • The long extract from Goldstein's book stalls the narrative badly
Cover of The Master and Margarita
The Master and Margarita

1966 · Essential

  • Two novels in one, Moscow farce and Jerusalem tragedy, that rhyme rather than repeat
  • Woland's retinue, above all Behemoth the cat, are among fiction's great comic creations
  • Unrevised at Bulgakov's death, and some loose threads and repetitions show

Where the gap is

Ideas
10.09.7
Story
9.08.9
Writing
9.19.4
Characters
8.19.3

At a glance

Fact1984The Master and Margarita
Released8 June 19491966
AuthorGeorge OrwellRina Sawayama, Mikhail Bulgakov
PublisherSecker & WarburgYMCA-Press
Pages328432 pages (Penguin Classics)
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · PoliticsFantasy · Literary fiction · Satire
Translator—Richard Pevear, Larissa Volokhonsky

The two verdicts

1984

1984: Orwell's cold, exact nightmare has lost none of its bite

1984 has flaws a modern editor would flag: an underwritten heroine, a lecture dropped into the thriller and a mood that never lifts. None of them dents its achievement. Few books have given readers such durable language for recognising how power manipulates truth, and fewer still have done it in prose this clear. That near-unmatched influence and enduring precision earn it a place among the landmarks of the form.

Read the full review →

The Master and Margarita

The Master and Margarita: the Devil's comedy that outlived the state it mocked

Few novels manage to be this funny about this much darkness. Bulgakov wrote a book he knew he would not see printed, about a city where honesty was dangerous, and filled it with a talking cat, a magic show and a Devil with impeccable manners, then set beside it the plainest and saddest retelling of Pilate's judgement in modern fiction. The structure sprawls in places, the text is not quite finished, and some of the satire needs annotation to land. None of that weighs much against the ideas, the characters and the sheer nerve of the thing. It sits just below the very top of our scale only because its rough edges are real; as a reading experience, it remains one of the essential novels of the last century.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.