Skip to content

Head to head

A Game of Thrones vs Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

A Game of Thrones takes it by 0.6, 8.6 against 8.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of A Game of Thrones
A Game of Thrones

1996 · Excellent

  • Rotating viewpoint chapters make every faction feel human and motivated
  • Tyrion, Arya and Jon are vivid, memorable creations from their first pages
  • A large cast and heavy heraldry make the opening third slow going
Cover of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
  • Diagon Alley and Hogwarts are bursting with playful, memorable invention
  • Harry, Ron and Hermione's friendship forms naturally and convincingly
  • The central mystery is slight and resolved through convenient rule-breaking

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.28.2
Story
9.07.8
Writing
8.17.4
Characters
9.28.4

At a glance

FactA Game of ThronesHarry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone
Released1 August 199626 June 1997
AuthorGeorge R.R. MartinJ. K. Rowling
PublisherBantam SpectraBloomsbury
Pages694309
GenreAdventure · Drama · FantasyAdventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

A Game of Thrones

A Game of Thrones: the fantasy that swapped prophecy for politics and consequence

A Game of Thrones earns its reputation through character, structure and a genuinely unpredictable approach to consequence. Its slow start, occasionally leaden exposition and troubling content hold it back from the very highest rank, and it resolves little on its own. As the opening of a saga and as a reinvention of what epic fantasy could do, though, it remains excellent.

Read the full review →

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone: a warm, witty doorway into a lasting world

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone is a delightful, imaginatively rich opening that established a world millions have wanted to live in. Its thin mystery, cartoonish villains and plain prose place it below the series' strongest entries and the great classics of children's fantasy. It is still an excellent debut and a near-perfect gateway into reading for younger audiences.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.