A Game of Thrones · 1996
A Game of Thrones: the fantasy that swapped prophecy for politics and consequence
A Game of Thrones, George R.R. Martin's 1996 opening to A Song of Ice and Fire, trades fantasy comfort for ruthless politics. Gripping, if slow to ignite.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
A Game of Thrones arrived at a time when epic fantasy was dominated by farm boys, dark lords and clearly drawn moral lines, and it quietly dismantled all three. Martin took the architecture of Tolkien-influenced fantasy and filled it with the logic of the Wars of the Roses: marriages as treaties, oaths as liabilities, and a willingness to let decent people lose. That approach reshaped the genre for a generation of writers and readers.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #31
- Of 61 books reviewed
- 1996
- Released
- 694
- Pages
It is not a flawless book. The opening is dense, the prose workmanlike and some of its content hard to defend. But few fantasy novels are this compulsively readable once the pieces start moving.
The appendices are not optional reading for many newcomers, and the first few hundred pages ask for patience while the board is set up.
Viewpoint as a weapon
Each chapter is told from the perspective of a single character, and Martin uses the device brilliantly. Readers see the same events through the eyes of rivals and discover that almost no one thinks of themselves as a villain. A Stark child's terror, a Lannister's contempt and a young exile's growing resolve all sit side by side, and the effect is a world that feels argued over rather than simply described.
The structure also builds suspense in a way single-narrator fantasy rarely manages. Chapters routinely break at moments of crisis, and the next one sends the reader hundreds of miles away.

A cast that carries it
Tyrion Lannister, the sharp-tongued, underestimated younger son of the wealthiest house in the realm, is the standout: funny, bitter and far more principled than his family would like. Arya, a headstrong girl uninterested in the ladylike future expected of her, and Jon Snow, a bastard son seeking a place among the Night's Watch, give the book its emotional spine. Daenerys's chapters, following her transformation in a foreign culture, are the most traditionally mythic strand.
The characterisation has real depth, but the sheer number of houses, bannermen and family trees can overwhelm. The appendices are not optional reading for many newcomers, and the first few hundred pages ask for patience while the board is set up.
Politics over prophecy
The novel's central innovation is that the supernatural remains mostly at the edges. The threat beyond the Wall and the legacy of dragons are present from the prologue onward, but they are rationed, while the court intrigue in King's Landing drives the plot. That restraint makes the magic feel dangerous rather than decorative.
Less defensible is the book's treatment of sexuality and violence against women and children. Martin argues for historical grimness, and some of it serves the story, but several scenes, especially those involving very young characters, feel gratuitous and have drawn sustained criticism.
Who it is for
It suits readers who enjoy political thrillers, historical fiction and large casts as much as those who love fantasy. Anyone who has only seen the television adaptation will find the book richer in interior life, though largely faithful in outline. Those who dislike cliffhangers should know it is the opening of an unfinished series.
What works
- Rotating viewpoint chapters make every faction feel human and motivated
- Tyrion, Arya and Jon are vivid, memorable creations from their first pages
- Political scheming has genuine stakes and unforgiving consequences
- Hints of magic are rationed, so each supernatural moment lands hard
What doesn’t
- A large cast and heavy heraldry make the opening third slow going
- Sexual content involving very young characters is gratuitous and jarring
- Ends a volume, not a story, in a series whose later books have been long delayed
Head to head
- Ideas
- 8.28.2
- Story
- 9.07.8
- Writing
- 8.17.4
- Characters
- 9.28.4
A Game of Thrones edges it by 0.6. See them side by side
The verdict
A Game of Thrones earns its reputation through character, structure and a genuinely unpredictable approach to consequence. Its slow start, occasionally leaden exposition and troubling content hold it back from the very highest rank, and it resolves little on its own. As the opening of a saga and as a reinvention of what epic fantasy could do, though, it remains excellent.




