Skip to content

Head to head

Absolute Batman vs All-Star Superman

All-Star Superman takes it by 0.8, 9.4 against 8.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Absolute Batman
Absolute Batman

2024 · Excellent

  • Dragotta's huge, armoured Batman reads as a new design, not a costume swap
  • A working-class Bruce gives the old origin a fresh set of stakes
  • Black Mask's Party Animals are louder than they are interesting as a threat
Cover of All-Star Superman
All-Star Superman

2005 · Essential

  • Quitely's Clark Kent is a physical comedy of slouches, so the disguise finally works
  • Every issue is a complete story, and most could stand alone as a one-shot
  • The density of invented science and cameos can lose readers new to Superman's history

Where the gap is

Art
9.49.7
Story
8.39.3
Pacing
8.08.6
Characters
8.69.5

At a glance

FactAbsolute BatmanAll-Star Superman
Released9 October 20242005
WriterScott SnyderGrant Morrison
ArtistNick Dragotta, Gabriel Hernández WaltaFrank Quitely, Jamie Grant
PublisherDC ComicsDC Comics
IssuesOngoing monthly since 9 October 2024; the first arc, The Zoo, is issues #1–6Twelve issues, published from November 2005 to October 2008
GenreAction · Superhero · CrimeAdventure · Sci-Fi · Superhero

The two verdicts

Absolute Batman

Absolute Batman: a Dark Knight with no fortune, and all the more frightening for it

The Zoo succeeds at the hardest job a reinvention has: it makes a character this familiar feel unknown again. Removing the fortune turns Batman from a man with every advantage into one who has to make his own, and Dragotta's design puts that idea on every page. The score stops short of the essential tier because the arc's antagonist never becomes more than a set of masks, the narration sometimes talks over the art, and the six issues are as much a foundation as a finished story. As a beginning, though, it is the strongest case DC has made in years for starting a hero from scratch.

Read the full review →

All-Star Superman

All-Star Superman: the kindest superhero comic ever made, and one of the strangest

All-Star Superman takes a character often dismissed as too powerful to be interesting and finds the interest in what he chooses to do with that power. Morrison's compressed, inventive scripts and Quitely's gentle, heavy, funny drawing make a book that reads quickly and lingers for years. The score sits just below the top tier because the middle of the run loosens its grip, and because its pleasure in Superman's history will occasionally leave a newcomer a step behind. Neither stops it from being the version of the character worth handing to anyone who asks where to start, and the rare superhero story whose final lesson is simply to be good to people.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.