Skip to content

Head to head

Alan Wake 2 vs Silent Hill f

Alan Wake 2 takes it by 0.7, 8.9 against 8.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Alan Wake 2
Alan Wake 2

2023 · Excellent

  • Two campaigns that genuinely inform and unsettle one another
  • Live-action footage blended into the game world with real confidence
  • Combat is stiff and repetitive once the novelty of the flashlight fades
Cover of Silent Hill f
Silent Hill f

2025 · Excellent

  • Ebisugaoka is a 1960s mountain town recreated down to its shop signs and rice terraces
  • Spider lilies and rot replace rust and blood, giving the series a new visual grammar
  • Melee fights go on too long and too often for a game this interested in dread

Where the gap is

Story
9.38.8
Gameplay
7.97.1
Longevity
7.67.9
Presentation
9.59.3

At a glance

FactAlan Wake 2Silent Hill f
Released27 October 202325 September 2025
DeveloperRemedy EntertainmentNeoBards Entertainment
PublisherEpic GamesKonami, Konami Digital Entertainment
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|SPlayStation 5, PC (Windows), Xbox Series X|S
DirectorSam LakeAl Yang
EngineNorthlightUnreal Engine 5
GenreAdventure · HorrorAction · Horror · Psychological

The two verdicts

Alan Wake 2

Alan Wake 2: Remedy's boldest, strangest and most confident horror game

Alan Wake 2 earns its high score on the strength of its storytelling, structure and presentation, which are exceptional and often genuinely original. Its combat and pacing hold it back from the very top tier, but few horror games of recent years are as memorable, as ambitious or as unmistakably the work of one studio's singular vision.

Read the full review →

Silent Hill f

Silent Hill f: the series leaves the town behind and finds its nerve again

Silent Hill f succeeds at the thing that was hardest to do: it gives a famous, tired series a new place, a new visual language and a protagonist with something to say, and it does so with enormous craft. Ebisugaoka is one of the most memorable settings in horror games, and the sound and art direction alone justify the visit. The score stops short of the essential tier because the combat is both too present and too thin, and because the full story is gated behind playthroughs that repeat more than they add in play terms. Players who can tolerate the fights will find a sincere, unsettling and often beautiful game about growing up under pressure. Those who cannot should know in advance that the fog is thick with them.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.