Skip to content

Head to head

All-Star Superman vs The Sandman

Dead level: both score 9.4. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of All-Star Superman
All-Star Superman

2005 · Essential

  • Quitely's Clark Kent is a physical comedy of slouches, so the disguise finally works
  • Every issue is a complete story, and most could stand alone as a one-shot
  • The density of invented science and cameos can lose readers new to Superman's history
Cover of The Sandman
The Sandman

1989 · Essential

  • The Endless are among the most memorable characters in modern fantasy
  • Standalone tales such as A Midsummer Night's Dream rank with comics' finest
  • The early issues lean on DC horror and superhero trappings that feel dated

Where the gap is

Art
9.78.6
Story
9.39.5
Pacing
8.68.7
Characters
9.59.6

At a glance

FactAll-Star SupermanThe Sandman
Released20051989
WriterGrant MorrisonNeil Gaiman
ArtistFrank Quitely, Jamie GrantSam Kieth
PublisherDC ComicsDC Comics
IssuesTwelve issues, published from November 2005 to October 200875
GenreAdventure · Sci-Fi · SuperheroDrama · Fantasy · Graphic Novel

The two verdicts

All-Star Superman

All-Star Superman: the kindest superhero comic ever made, and one of the strangest

All-Star Superman takes a character often dismissed as too powerful to be interesting and finds the interest in what he chooses to do with that power. Morrison's compressed, inventive scripts and Quitely's gentle, heavy, funny drawing make a book that reads quickly and lingers for years. The score sits just below the top tier because the middle of the run loosens its grip, and because its pleasure in Superman's history will occasionally leave a newcomer a step behind. Neither stops it from being the version of the character worth handing to anyone who asks where to start, and the rare superhero story whose final lesson is simply to be good to people.

Read the full review →

The Sandman

The Sandman is a vast mythic tapestry about stories, change and the price of pride

The Sandman is an extraordinary achievement, a rich and moving meditation on myth, responsibility and change that expanded what mainstream comics could be. Its uneven early issues, inconsistent art and occasionally meandering structure prevent a perfect score. A 9.4 recognises an exceptional series that remains one of the most influential works in the medium.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.