Skip to content

Head to head

Asterios Polyp vs Fun Home

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Asterios Polyp
Asterios Polyp

2009 · Essential

  • Every character has a drawing style, a typeface and a balloon shape of their own
  • Colour carries meaning: who is in the room changes how the room is printed
  • Asterios is an insufferable lecturer, and the book makes you sit through the lectures
Cover of Fun Home
Fun Home

2006 · Essential

  • A father drawn with enough affection and exactness that he never becomes a type
  • Every panel is composed and captioned so the images and the narration disagree usefully
  • Narration is so dense that a first read can feel like homework

Where the gap is

Art
9.89.0
Story
8.89.0
Pacing
8.78.8
Characters
8.99.4

At a glance

FactAsterios PolypFun Home
Released7 July 20098 June 2006
WriterDavid MazzucchelliAlison Bechdel
ArtistDavid MazzucchelliAlison Bechdel
PublisherPantheon BooksHoughton Mifflin
IssuesOne volume: an original graphic novel, not serialisedOne self-contained graphic memoir in seven chapters; no serialisation
GenreDrama · Literary fiction · Graphic NovelDrama · Graphic Novel · Memoir

The two verdicts

Asterios Polyp

Asterios Polyp: a man who thinks in diagrams, drawn so you can watch him do it

*Asterios Polyp* is a graphic novel in which the drawing is not a vehicle for the story but the place where the story happens. Mazzucchelli uses style, colour and lettering to show how two people perceive each other, and he does it with a control few cartoonists have matched before or since. The score stops short of the very top for reasons the book's admirers will recognise: a hero who is a chore before he is a person, a scheme of opposites drawn so cleanly that some scenes feel solved in advance, and closing pages that will split the room. None of that changes what it achieves. For anyone curious about what comics can do that no other medium can, it remains one of the first books to hand them.

Read the full review →

Fun Home

Fun Home: a memoir that makes a family's silence readable, panel by panel

Fun Home is an essential graphic memoir and one of the few comics that works as literature without apology. Bechdel's control of structure, her father's portrait and the way her pictures argue with her captions make it a book that gets better the more you return to it. The score stops short of the top tier because the density is real, the opening chapters ask for more patience than most readers expect, and some of the book is hard to sit through. Those are small prices. Anyone who reads comics for their ideas, or reads memoir for its honesty, should read it, and most other adults will not regret it.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.