Skip to content
Comic reviewEssential#10 in comics

Asterios Polyp · 2009

Asterios Polyp: a man who thinks in diagrams, drawn so you can watch him do it

Asterios Polyp review. David Mazzucchelli's 2009 graphic novel about a fallen architect turns colour, line and lettering into characterisation.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán8 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Most comics use their drawing style the way a novel uses its typeface: once chosen, it disappears. Asterios Polyp refuses that bargain on nearly every page. David Mazzucchelli draws his architect hero as a set of cylinders and cubes when he is sure of himself, draws his wife in soft cross-hatched strokes, and lets the two styles collide when the marriage does. The result is a graphic novel whose form is its argument, and one of the few that could not be adapted into anything else without losing the point.

9.1
Editorial score
#10
Of 53 comics reviewed
2009
Released
9.8
Best at: Art

It arrived in July 2009 from an artist many readers knew only through other people's characters. Mazzucchelli had drawn Daredevil: Born Again and Batman: Year One in the eighties, then stepped away from superheroes into smaller, stranger work. This was his first long book as sole author, and he did everything on it himself, down to the lettering. That control is visible on every page. It is also, now and then, a little airless.

The premise

Asterios Polyp is an architect who has become famous without building very much. He teaches at Cornell, lectures with total certainty, and believes most questions have two sides, one of which is wrong. On a stormy night his New York apartment is hit by lightning and burns. He walks away from the ruins with almost nothing, buys a bus ticket with the cash in his wallet, and rides until the money runs out. That leaves him in Apogee, a small town somewhere in the American interior, working as a car mechanic and lodging with his employer's family.

The present-day story is quiet and almost comic: a man of grand theories learning to fix brake pads. Threaded through it are long sections from the past, his childhood, his teaching, and above all his marriage to Hana, a sculptor as unsure of herself as he is sure of himself. These are told by Ignazio, the twin brother who died at birth, a narrator who knows Asterios better than Asterios does and has no reason to flatter him. The device sounds whimsical. On the page it works as a cool, slightly mournful conscience.

A book that argues about form versus function, built so that every one of its forms has a function.

Asterios Polyp
Asterios PolypA page from Asterios Polyp by David Mazzucchelli; scan by Grumblepuss, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The writing

The story is assembled from opposites, and the book does not hide it. Reason and emotion, symmetry and accident, Apollo and Dionysus, nature and nurture: Asterios sorts the world into pairs, and Mazzucchelli builds a plot that keeps refusing to stay sorted. The Orpheus myth runs underneath, in names and dream sequences and one memorable descent, and the Odyssey supplies a loose shape for the journey. Readers who like a story that knows its sources will find plenty to dig for.

The cost is that the scheme is sometimes too legible. A dinner-party argument about art or one of the dream sequences can play like an illustrated lecture, made with great wit but with the conclusion already chalked on the board. Mazzucchelli is aware of this. The book teases its hero for exactly this habit, and a good share of its humour comes from watching him explain things to people who did not ask. Even so, there are stretches in the second half where the design is doing more work than the drama.

Where the writing is strongest is in small, specific scenes. A first meeting at a faculty party. A row conducted entirely through what two people choose not to say. A conversation in a garage that reveals more about the mechanic's family than about the car. The dialogue is spare and precise, and the funniest lines usually belong to people Asterios underestimates.

  1. 1986

    Draws Daredevil: Born Again, written by Frank Miller, for Marvel

  2. 1987

    Batman: Year One, again with Frank Miller, runs in Batman for DC

  3. 1991

    Begins Rubber Blanket, a self-published anthology made with Richmond Lewis

  4. 1994

    Co-adapts Paul Auster's City of Glass with Paul Karasik

  5. 2009

    Asterios Polyp is published by Pantheon on 7 July

  6. 2010

    Wins three Eisner Awards, three Harvey Awards and the first Los Angeles Times Book Prize for a graphic novel

The art

This is where the book earns its reputation. Every major character has a visual signature: a line weight, a way of being shaded, a lettering style and a shape of speech balloon. Asterios's balloons are hard-edged and his lettering mechanical; Hana's words are softer and more hand-drawn; other figures each get their own typographic voice. You learn to identify a speaker from the balloon before you look at the face, and that habit pays off when two of these voices begin to bleed into one another.

Colour works the same way. The palette is narrow, a few flat inks rather than full painted colour, and the choice of ink tracks who is present and how they feel. When Asterios is alone with his ideas, the page turns schematic and cool. When Hana enters, warmer tones arrive with her. In the best-known sequences, an argument literally separates them into two incompatible styles of drawing, him a wireframe and her a sketch, and the page itself becomes the quarrel. It is the kind of effect only comics can do, and Mazzucchelli does it without a caption to explain it.

Behind the high concept there is plain craft. Faces are expressive with very few lines, the town of Apogee feels lived in, and the page layouts, mostly calm grids, break open at just the right moments. Anyone who knows the shadowy realism of Batman: Year One will barely recognise the same hand, which is part of the point.

How it reads

Visual invention
10/10
Line, colour and lettering all carry meaning
Emotional warmth
6/10
Earned late, held at arm's length early
Density of ideas
9/10
Myth, design theory and philosophy on most pages
Ease of entry
7/10
Plainly told, but it rewards attention
Rereading pull
9/10
Patterns surface the second time through
Gallery · 3 imagesEdition cover via Open Library

Characters

Asterios is a difficult hero to spend 344 pages with. He is clever, funny in his dry way and capable of real tenderness, and he is also a bore, a snob and the kind of man who corrects his wife's guests. The book knows all this; Ignazio's narration is often quietly withering. Readers who need to like a protagonist will struggle in the first hundred pages, before Apogee begins to soften the edges.

Hana is the book's best creation, and the reason the flashbacks hold. She is a gifted artist with no talent for self-promotion, married to a man with no gift for anything else, and her slow loss of confidence is drawn with great care. The people of Apogee, a mechanic, his wife and their young son, begin as comic relief and turn into something more generous. If the book has a weakness here, it is that some of them exist mainly to show Asterios what he is missing.

Format and editions

Asterios Polyp was never serialised. It appeared whole, as a 344-page hardcover, which suits a book whose effects depend on patterns that build across hundreds of pages. It sits in the same Pantheon list that brought [Maus](/item/maus) and Persepolis to bookshops, among graphic novels that general readers come to without any knowledge of comics.

Editions worth knowing
EditionPublisherYearNote
English, hardcoverPantheon Books2009The first edition, with the short dust jacket
FrenchCasterman2010Same cover design, translated lettering
SpanishSinsentido2010The first Spanish edition

Translation is a real question for a book where typeface is characterisation, and the foreign editions had to reinvent each character's lettering. Readers who can manage English should read the original, where every balloon is Mazzucchelli's own hand.

For you if

  • Readers who already love comics and want to see what the form can do that prose and film cannot
  • Anyone interested in design, architecture or typography; the book is full of all three
  • Readers of literary fiction about marriage, ego and second chances

Not for you if

  • Anyone who needs a likeable protagonist from the first page
  • Readers who find visible symbolism heavy-handed rather than playful
  • Those looking for Mazzucchelli's superhero work; this is a different artist in all but name

For readers who come to this book through his earlier work, the contrast is the attraction, and it runs both ways.

What works

  • Every character has a drawing style, a typeface and a balloon shape of their own
  • Colour carries meaning: who is in the room changes how the room is printed
  • Ignazio's narration lets the book argue with its hero without a single caption of blame
  • One self-contained volume, with no prior reading and no sequel to wait for

What doesn’t

  • Asterios is an insufferable lecturer, and the book makes you sit through the lectures
  • Its dualities are drawn so clearly that a few scenes read like a seminar diagram
  • The closing pages divide readers who are otherwise won over

Head to head

Art
9.89.9
Story
8.89.0
Pacing
8.78.4
Characters
8.99.1

Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth edges it by 0.1. See them side by side

EssentialHow we score

The verdict

Asterios Polyp is a graphic novel in which the drawing is not a vehicle for the story but the place where the story happens. Mazzucchelli uses style, colour and lettering to show how two people perceive each other, and he does it with a control few cartoonists have matched before or since. The score stops short of the very top for reasons the book's admirers will recognise: a hero who is a chore before he is a person, a scheme of opposites drawn so cleanly that some scenes feel solved in advance, and closing pages that will split the room. None of that changes what it achieves. For anyone curious about what comics can do that no other medium can, it remains one of the first books to hand them.

Quick answers

Is Asterios Polyp worth reading?

Voxizer scores Asterios Polyp (2009) 9.1 out of 10 — essential. Asterios Polyp is a graphic novel in which the drawing is not a vehicle for the story but the place where the story happens. Mazzucchelli uses style, colour and lettering to show how two people perceive each other, and he does it with a control few cartoonists have matched before or since.

Who will enjoy Asterios Polyp?

Readers who already love comics and want to see what the form can do that prose and film cannot. Anyone interested in design, architecture or typography; the book is full of all three. Readers of literary fiction about marriage, ego and second chances.

Who should skip Asterios Polyp?

Anyone who needs a likeable protagonist from the first page. Readers who find visible symbolism heavy-handed rather than playful. Those looking for Mazzucchelli's superhero work; this is a different artist in all but name.

What is Asterios Polyp like, in short?

A graphic novel about a brilliant, self-satisfied architect whose life burns down, literally, in the first pages. Line, colour and lettering are used as characterisation, which is the reason to read it. The hero is hard to like by design; the book is better at diagnosing him than forgiving him. One volume, 344 pages, no prior reading; it rewards a second pass more than most comics.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Asterios Polyp yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.