Skip to content

Head to head

Asterios Polyp vs Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth

Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth takes it by 0.1, 9.2 against 9.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Asterios Polyp
Asterios Polyp

2009 · Essential

  • Every character has a drawing style, a typeface and a balloon shape of their own
  • Colour carries meaning: who is in the room changes how the room is printed
  • Asterios is an insufferable lecturer, and the book makes you sit through the lectures
Cover of Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth
  • Page layouts that control time as precisely as a film editor, panel by panel
  • Flat, muted colour that turns weather, wallpaper and snow into mood
  • Long wordless stretches and tiny lettering demand a patience many readers lack

Where the gap is

Art
9.89.9
Story
8.89.0
Pacing
8.78.4
Characters
8.99.1

At a glance

FactAsterios PolypJimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth
Released7 July 200912 September 2000
WriterDavid MazzucchelliChris Ware
ArtistDavid MazzucchelliChris Ware
PublisherPantheon BooksPantheon Books
IssuesOne volume: an original graphic novel, not serialisedOne volume, collecting and revising The Acme Novelty Library #5–6, 8–9 and 11–14 (1995–2000) and strips first run in Newcity from 1992
GenreDrama · Literary fiction · Graphic NovelDrama · Literary fiction · Graphic Novel

The two verdicts

Asterios Polyp

Asterios Polyp: a man who thinks in diagrams, drawn so you can watch him do it

*Asterios Polyp* is a graphic novel in which the drawing is not a vehicle for the story but the place where the story happens. Mazzucchelli uses style, colour and lettering to show how two people perceive each other, and he does it with a control few cartoonists have matched before or since. The score stops short of the very top for reasons the book's admirers will recognise: a hero who is a chore before he is a person, a scheme of opposites drawn so cleanly that some scenes feel solved in advance, and closing pages that will split the room. None of that changes what it achieves. For anyone curious about what comics can do that no other medium can, it remains one of the first books to hand them.

Read the full review →

Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth

Jimmy Corrigan: the loneliest comic ever drawn, and one of the most exact

*Jimmy Corrigan* is a landmark of its medium in a narrow sense: few comics have shown so clearly how page layout, colour and repetition can make time and silence into the subject of a story. Its account of a son, a father and a grandfather is precise and unsentimental, and it lingers long after the book is closed. The score stops short of the very top because the same qualities that make it remarkable also make it gruelling. The middle stretch tests patience more than it rewards it, and Jimmy's passivity can feel airless. Those are real costs. For a reader willing to pay them, this is one of the most distinctive graphic novels ever published, and a book that changes how other comics look afterwards.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.