Skip to content

Head to head

Atari 2600 vs Sega Dreamcast

Dead level: both score 8.8. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Atari 2600
Atari 2600

1977 · Excellent

  • The cartridge slot turned a single-game toy into a platform anyone could write for
  • Woodgrain, ribbed black plastic and chunky switches made it look like living-room hi-fi
  • No frame buffer and two sprites mean flicker and blocky shapes in most busy games
Cover of Sega Dreamcast
Sega Dreamcast

1998 · Excellent

  • Shared NAOMI architecture made arcade conversions near-identical at home
  • A modem in the box, years before online play was normal on consoles
  • The controller is bulky, with too few buttons for fighting games

Where the gap is

Value
7.97.6
Design
9.38.8
Features
8.49.3
Performance
6.98.6

At a glance

FactAtari 2600Sega Dreamcast
Released197727 November 1998
MakerAtari, Inc.Sega
TypeHome video game console (second generation, 8-bit)Home video game console (sixth generation)
GpuTelevision Interface Adaptor (TIA), designed by Jay Miner; no frame buffer, graphics drawn one scan line at a timeNEC PowerVR2 (PowerVR2 DC), over 3 million polygons per second by Sega's figure
CoresMOS Technology 6507, a cost-reduced 6502 with 13 address pinsHitachi SH-4 32-bit RISC with 128-bit graphics-oriented FPU (360 MIPS, 1.4 GFLOPS)
Speed1.19 MHz200 MHz CPU; 100 MHz GPU
GenreGaming · Console · RetroGaming · Console · Retro

The two verdicts

Atari 2600

Atari 2600: the woodgrain box that turned a cartridge slot into an industry

The Atari 2600 earns its place on two counts that pull in opposite directions. Its design, from the woodgrain case to the joystick, is close to timeless, and its cartridge slot changed how games were sold for everyone who came after. Its silicon, by contrast, was built to last a couple of years and was asked to last fifteen, and the strain shows in flicker, sameness and a library diluted by a market it could not police. The score reflects a landmark of the medium whose importance outruns its usefulness today: essential to understand, rewarding in short doses, and best experienced through a replica unless the original box itself is the point.

Read the full review →

Sega Dreamcast

Sega Dreamcast: the console that got the future right and ran out of time to profit from it

The Dreamcast earns its score on ideas and on what it did with modest parts. It brought Sega's arcade games home with almost nothing lost, put a modem in every box before the internet was a household utility, and made the memory card into a second screen. It did all of this on a budget chipset and an inexpensive disc format that were already looking thin when the PlayStation 2 arrived. The controller is the one design choice that has aged badly, and the value mark reflects what owning one means now: an ageing optical drive, a region lock and a reliance on enthusiasts for services Sega switched off long ago. As a piece of consumer electronics it was a commercial failure. As a design for what consoles would become, it was right about almost everything.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.