Skip to content

Head to head

Atlanta vs Fleabag

Fleabag takes it by 0.5, 9.3 against 8.8. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Atlanta
Atlanta

2016 · Excellent

  • Standalone episodes such as Teddy Perkins are among television's boldest
  • Brian Tyree Henry gives Alfred enormous weariness and dignity
  • The third season's anthology detours sideline the main cast
Cover of Fleabag
Fleabag

2016 · Essential

  • Uses direct address to the camera with dazzling comic and emotional effect
  • The second season is a near-perfect romantic tragicomedy
  • The first season is rougher and more reliant on shock humour

Where the gap is

Craft
9.19.2
Story
8.49.1
Characters
9.09.4
Performances
9.29.7

At a glance

FactAtlantaFleabag
Released6 September 201621 July 2016
Created byDonald GloverPhoebe Waller Bridge
StarringDonald Glover, Brian Tyree Henry, LaKeith StanfieldPhoebe Waller Bridge, Sian Clifford, Olivia Colman
NetworkFXBBC Three
Seasons42
Episodes4112
GenreDrama · ComedyDrama · Comedy

The two verdicts

Atlanta

Atlanta: Donald Glover's surreal, restless comedy that refused to sit still

Atlanta scores 8.8 for its fearless formal ambition, a lead ensemble of rare quality and a string of episodes that rank with the most inventive in modern television. The third season's detours and the occasional episode that never lands keep it just below the level of the medium's absolute greats, but its influence and originality are beyond question.

Read the full review →

Fleabag

Fleabag: twelve episodes of comedy so sharp it leaves a wound

Fleabag scores 9.3 for writing of extraordinary precision, a lead performance of rare range and a second season that stands among the finest in British television. A slightly rougher first season and a scale that leaves some supporting players underexplored keep it a fraction below the all-time landmarks, but few comedies have ever been this funny and this sad at once.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.