Skip to content
Series reviewExcellent

Atlanta · 2016

Atlanta: Donald Glover's surreal, restless comedy that refused to sit still

Our review of Atlanta, Donald Glover's FX series: a daring, funny, unsettling portrait of Black life and fame that grew stranger over four seasons.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Few series have changed shape as often, or as deliberately, as Atlanta. It began as a low-key comedy about a young man hustling to make rent and ended as something closer to an anthology of dreams, satires and horror stories about being Black in America. Donald Glover and his collaborators, including director Hiro Murai and writer Stephen Glover, treated each episode as a chance to try something new, and the hit rate is remarkably high.

8.8
Editorial score
#22
Of 109 series reviewed
2016
Released
4
Seasons

That experimentation is both the show's glory and its limitation. When Atlanta connects, it is unlike anything else on television. When it does not, it can feel like a sketchbook rather than a finished work.

The best way in is to accept that the show's rules can change at any moment, and that this is the point.

Story and structure

The first season is the most conventional, following Earn as he tries to turn his cousin's local success into a career. Even here, the show slips easily into the absurd: an invisible car, a talk show complete with fake commercials, a party where nothing is quite as it seems. The second season, subtitled Robbin' Season, is widely regarded as the peak, sharpening the sense of danger around money and fame and producing Teddy Perkins, an extended, commercial-free nightmare about a reclusive musician's mansion that works as both horror film and study of celebrity trauma.

The third season, set largely on a European tour, interleaves the main plot with self-contained stories featuring new characters, each probing race and guilt from a different angle. Some are brilliant; others feel like essays. The fourth season returns to Atlanta and finds a better balance, closing the series with a mix of confidence and melancholy.

Atlanta
Atlanta

Characters and performances

The core quartet is superb. Glover's Earn is watchful and quietly desperate, often the least expressive man in the room. Brian Tyree Henry makes Alfred the show's emotional centre, a man who wants success but resents what it asks of him. LaKeith Stanfield turns Darius into a deadpan oracle whose non sequiturs somehow make sense, and Zazie Beetz gives Van an arc of real frustration and self-discovery, particularly in episodes built around her alone.

Watch
Atlanta — trailer

Direction and craft

Hiro Murai's direction defines the show's texture. Scenes play out in long, patient takes, the camera often keeping a slight distance, so that ordinary moments acquire a low hum of menace. Music is used sparingly and precisely. The show's handling of tone, sliding from broad comedy to dread without warning, is one of its hardest-won achievements and something few imitators have managed.

Gallery · 3 imagesFX Networks

Who it is for

Atlanta rewards viewers who enjoy surprise and ambiguity and do not need every episode to advance a plot. Anyone expecting a traditional sitcom or a straightforward music-industry drama is likely to be puzzled. The best way in is to accept that the show's rules can change at any moment, and that this is the point.

What works

  • Standalone episodes such as Teddy Perkins are among television's boldest
  • Brian Tyree Henry gives Alfred enormous weariness and dignity
  • Hiro Murai's direction turns everyday scenes quietly uncanny
  • Jokes and social observation are sharp without ever lecturing

What doesn’t

  • The third season's anthology detours sideline the main cast
  • Loose plotting means some episodes drift without a payoff
  • The shifts in tone can feel wilfully opaque to some viewers

Head to head

Craft
9.19.2
Story
8.49.1
Characters
9.09.4
Performances
9.29.7

Fleabag edges it by 0.5. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Atlanta scores 8.8 for its fearless formal ambition, a lead ensemble of rare quality and a string of episodes that rank with the most inventive in modern television. The third season's detours and the occasional episode that never lands keep it just below the level of the medium's absolute greats, but its influence and originality are beyond question.

Quick answers

Is Atlanta worth watching?

Voxizer scores Atlanta (2016) 8.8 out of 10 — excellent. Atlanta scores 8. 8 for its fearless formal ambition, a lead ensemble of rare quality and a string of episodes that rank with the most inventive in modern television.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Atlanta yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for series: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.